PDA

View Full Version : Aus. Geo. to investigate ancient coins found on Wessell islands, 1944



bob10
4th June 2013, 06:09 AM
Well, been to the Wessell Islands, didn't know about the coins. Pity. Bob


From Aus. Geo. newsletter;
An Australian Geographic expedition aims to uncover the truth about ancient coins found off Arnhem Land in 1944.
http://www.australiangeographic.com.au/assets/images/article/journal/13744/ancient-coins-australia.jpg

The coins, which hail from Kilwa in modern-day Africa, are estimated to date back to the 12th Century. (Credit: Mike Owen)



AN UPCOMING EXPEDITION will attempt to uncover the truth behind five ancient African coins discovered on a beach in Arnhem Land in 1944.
The five coins, found by RAAF serviceman Morry Isenberg on the Northern Territory's Wessel Islands, hail from the medieval sultanate of Kilwa and are estimated to date back to the 12th century.
Mike Owen, a heritage consultant in Darwin, NT, who is leading the expedition, says the coins “have the capacity to redraft Australian history, in terms of a south-east Asian past.”
The Australian Geographic Society sponsored trip, scheduled for July, will attempt to uncover more clues from the site, following a hand-drawn map left by the serviceman.
Coin cache suggests early trade with Aborigines

Mike says the copper coins, which were not used outside of East Africa, probably held very little monetary value in Kilwa (centred on an island off modern-day Tanzania). “Yet, there they are – on a beach in north-east Arnhem Land, 10,000km east of where they originated, and perhaps seven to eight centuries apart,” he says, presenting a very great mystery.
The first recorded Europeans in the Wessels region were the Dutch in 1623. However, indigenous oral history from local Yolngu people is rich with visitors, says Dr Ian McIntosh, the expedition's lead researcher and anthropologist at Indiana University-Purdue University, in Indianapolis USA.
An adopted member of Arnhem Land’s Wangurri-Mandjikay clan and an Australian by birth, Ian has spoken in depth with the Yolngu people.
“There was much talk of the Wessels as a place of intense contact history,” he says. “The Wessels is very promising as a site for further exploration, for it may hold the keys to an earlier history of Australia not currently known in the history books.”
Ian also says that north Australia lies very close to the ancient Indian Ocean trade route that linked up Great Zimbabwe, Kilwa, Arabia and Persia, India and islands in Indonesia.
Treasure hunt for Australia’s early history

The Kilwa coins were discovered alongside four Dutch coins from the 17th and 18th centuries. Mike says the most interesting aspect of the coins is the enormous expanse of space and time they cover. “This could either mean one unlucky collector of worthless coins, or routine visitation and multiple [ship]wrecks,” he says.
Another possibility being explored is that the coins were gifted to the local Aboriginal people in exchange for use of the freshwater lagoon in Jensen Bay.

http://www.australiangeographic.com.au/assets/echo-island.jpg
Elcho Island is part of the Wessels chain in Arnhem Land, where the coins were discovered in 1944. (Credit: Mike Owen)
Researchers hope to test there theories with any results from the expedition in mid-July. A geomorphologist will also examine how the coastal landscape has changed since the coins were found. If shipwrecks are involved, how the coins washed up may provide clues to the location of a wreck, say the experts.
Meanwhile, anthropologists and a historian will work with local indigenous people to identify likely sites of contact with foreign visitors, while a heritage specialist will look after the documentation and ensure the site is protected.
“There is great interest on the part of Yolngu in this project, and in uncovering aspects of their own past,” says Ian.
An exclusive feature on the results of the expedition will feature in a future issue of the Australian Geographic journal.

loanrangie
4th June 2013, 06:15 PM
Interesting , coins look to have Arabic writing on them and being that Kilwa would be close to Zanzibar which was one of the major stop offs during the spice and slave trading era could mean Aborigines were collected as slaves ?

Bearman
4th June 2013, 06:42 PM
I guess we are naive to think the Dutch/Spaniards/English were the only ones to visit this continent in the past. There was even a rumour of the remains of a viking longboat unearthed years ago around the Gold Coast somewhere.

101RRS
4th June 2013, 06:59 PM
Of course the Spice Islands are just to the north west of the Wessels and the Wessels are really barrier islands off the north off Arnham land so it is not unreasonable that trading ships from the west following winds and off course could end up in that area and possibly wrecked. Also of course Maluccan traders from the Spice Islands are known to have traded with aborigines in that part of the world in the 12th and 13th centuries so could have brought these coins with them. There are heaps of options.

Chucaro
4th June 2013, 07:10 PM
I guess we are naive to think the Dutch/Spaniards/English were the only ones to visit this continent in the past. There was even a rumour of the remains of a viking longboat unearthed years ago around the Gold Coast somewhere.

Also the South Equatorial currents can bring boats for the west coast of South America.

https://www.aulro.com/afvb/images/imported/2013/06/1358.jpg

2stroke
4th June 2013, 07:37 PM
Remember reading of artifacts found with Tamil writing on them as well on the east coast. Herotodus (circa 500BC) wrote of an Egyptian pharoh who sent a flotilla of Phonecian ships to sail around "Lybia" as Africa was then called, they were said to have continued east until they were "beshoaled". He found it quite ridiculous that they reported that the sun was to their north as they sailed east.
Sea faring has been a human tradition for tens of millenia, after all aboriginies sailed here at least 50000 years ago and acrossed 75 to 100 km of water.
Well paddled or floated here, highly inlikely they actually "sailed"

101RRS
4th June 2013, 08:38 PM
after all aboriginies sailed here at least 50000 years ago and acrossed 75 to 100 km of water.
Well paddled or floated here, highly inlikely they actually "sailed"

Well I thought they walked here when there was no water.

Mick_Marsh
4th June 2013, 08:56 PM
Thai's fishermen traded with the Aborigines.
It's thought that's how the Dingos were introduced into Australia.

UncleHo
4th June 2013, 09:37 PM
Yes,Mick they are in someway related to the Cannan dog from memory.

Ferret
4th June 2013, 11:01 PM
...The coins, which hail from Kilwa in modern-day Africa, are estimated to date back to the 12th Century. (Credit: Mike Owen)

...The Kilwa coins were discovered alongside four Dutch coins from the 17th and 18th centuries.

Interesting find, but if found with Dutch coins from the 18th century then African sailors from the 12th century in Australia? Maybe not.

bee utey
4th June 2013, 11:02 PM
Well I thought they walked here when there was no water.
https://www.aulro.com/afvb/images/imported/2013/06/1324.jpg

It's why Australian/New Guinean fauna and flora has remained distinct despite global sea level changes.

Wallace Line - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

bob10
5th June 2013, 06:32 AM
I think the present theory is Aus. & N.G. were joined by a land mass, back in the days. Bob. From Aus. Geo.;

PNG find prompts human migration rethink

By:Julian Swallow | October-1-2010


49,000-year-old artefacts have been unearthed in PNG, suggesting a rethink of human migration patterns.
http://www.australiangeographic.com.au/assets/images/article/journal/7527/papua-new-guinea-png-village.jpg

The Ivane Valley in PNG, where 49,000 year-old artefacts have been uncovered. (Photo: Glenn Summerhayes and Andrew Fairbairn)



ANCIENT ARTEFACTS UNEARTHED IN the highlands of Papua New Guinea provide some of the earliest evidence of human settlement of Sahul, the primordial landmass that once joined Papua New Guinea with Australia.

Charred nut shells from pandanus trees, fragments of animal bone and the remains of stone axes were found in the remote Ivane Valley of south-eastern Papua New Guinea - near the famous Kokoda Track - by a team led by archaeology Professor Glenn Summerhayes from the University of Otago, New Zealand.

These artefacts, which have been dated to between 49,000 and 44,000 years old, may prompt a rethink of the traditional view that the prehistoric migration of people throughout the world took place along the coasts.

"This is among the earliest evidence of human habitation in this part of the world, or indeed any place outside Africa, India and the Middle East," Glenn told Australian Geographic. "Many models for the movements of people argue for a colonisation route along the coast, arguing that people were pre-adapted to a coastal way of life...Our evidence shows such a pre-adaptation would have been short lived as people moved into highland valleys as soon as they got out of their canoes."


http://www.australiangeographic.com.au/assets/Ivane-Valley-png-indigenous.jpgIvane Valley resident, Paul Lamui, demonstrates how to use rocks to crack pandanus nuts open - the same method used 49,000 years ago according to excavation evidence in the Ivane Valley of PNG. (Photo: Andrew Fairbairn)



"Cold, uncompromising place"

The team's study is published today in the journal Science.

Professor Peter Bellwood, an archaeologist at ANU who was not part of the team, agrees the wealth of evidence found in the Ivane Valley "provides the first reliable dates for the earliest habitation of the PNG Highlands."

Professor Chris Gosden from the University of Oxford - who writes a related article in the same issue of Science - says its unlikely early humans would have lived there permanently as it was a "cold, difficult and uncompromising place to live at any time over the past 50,000 years."

Starch grains from yams recovered in the valley appear to support this, having most likely been transported there from their natural habitat in the lower elevations closer to the country's steamy sub-tropical coast.

Highly mobile

Archaeologist Dr Andrew Fairbairn from the University of Queensland, who worked with Glenn on the research, says this suggests early humans lived in small nomadic populations that moved up and down the mountains of Papua New Guinea in search of food.

"They clearly were very mobile. We assume [they lived in] some form of egalitarian structure, but it's very difficult to say from the archaeological remains alone. It was a very cold period in history and these people were both resourceful and capable to be able to live at this altitude," he says.

Long isolated by water, Sahul is thought to have been colonised via canoe from Southeast Asia sometime after 50,000 years ago. While the Papua New Guinea Highlands was one of the areas first settled by the new arrivals, evidence exists of the presence of these early humans - who are also believed to be the ancestors of the modern Aboriginies - in Australia from around the same time.

While DNA evidence proves this common ancestral link between Australia's Aboriginies and their modern Melanesian cousins, rising sea levels around 8000 years ago seperated the two groups of people, leading to significant subsequent differences.


A map of the Ivane Valley in Papua New Guinea (Photo: AAAS)
http://www.australiangeographic.com.au/assets/papua-new-guinea-map-png.jpg