View Full Version : Should I get a aftermarket diff.
voltron
18th July 2014, 09:24 PM
Ive been reading abour various diff issues people have had in the past. As I just got back from a trip through NT, and that sort of country has me paranoid about reliability etc, but in the end all went well, and my faith in the Defender has been restored. I was just wandering if the diff in the 2.2 Puma has still been having issues. If it's a weak link I would rather change it out before any potential problem then wait for it to go bang. Im not having any issues currently but would rather have confidence in a proven diff then cross my fingers on the factory 110 diff.
Are people still having their Diff's fail on them.
What will a new aftermarket diff set me back cost wise?
Cheers.
Graham
n plus one
18th July 2014, 09:39 PM
Ive been reading abour various diff issues people have had in the past. As I just got back from a trip through NT, and that sort of country has me paranoid about reliability etc, but in the end all went well, and my faith in the Defender has been restored. I was just wandering if the diff in the 2.2 Puma has still been having issues. If it's a weak link I would rather change it out before any potential problem then wait for it to go bang. Im not having any issues currently but would rather have confidence in a proven diff then cross my fingers on the factory 110 diff.
Are people still having their Diff's fail on them.
What will a new aftermarket diff set me back cost wise?
Cheers.
Graham
Around $6k for a Nine Inch, $3k for a plough (Salisbury).
Mine hasn't failed (or given any issues) yet (100k), just about to fit a fully rebuilt P38 (with a locker) to mine - anticipate a further 100k + of heavy use without issue.
Would have gone an Ashcroft HDP38, but they're not currently available and I'm going to the Cape at the end of next month and wanted a locker fitted for the trip.
Sitec
18th July 2014, 09:51 PM
$3k for a plough (Salisbury)....
Plough!! They're awesome! I have one at either end and they're currently withstanding 200hp and 5.9 litres of Cummins Turbo Diesel... Know where my choice would be!! ;)
alittlebitconcerned
19th July 2014, 11:04 AM
I don't know enough to answer your question but if you decide to get a new diff you might want to consider an Ashcroft ATB. Plenty of info on the forum, cheaper and stronger than a new LR diff, and apparently 99% as effective as lockers
voltron
19th July 2014, 04:20 PM
Thanks Lads.
Plenty of info there to get me started.
:cool:
Summiitt
19th July 2014, 05:17 PM
What year is your 2.2, how many km? I've been punishing my 2012 130 with no issues, and to be honest I have no concerns regarding the diff reliability, remember, a busted diff is not normally a deal breaker, you can normally limp your way out of trouble..I'd leave your diff in and see how things go.
David Hawes
19th July 2014, 08:23 PM
I have a MY12 110 with 62,000 klms and what I thought was a diff whine turned out to be scalloped tyres. Two new rear tyres and no more whine. I did however investigate a replacement for the P38 as I also do a lot of remote area work. My solution was to fit an ARB air locker. This replaces all diff internals except crown wheel and pinion. According to research I did it tends to be the yokes and pins in the planetary gears that fail. The planeteries in the air locker are the same used in V8 comp trucks and are extremely robost. At about $2,500 fitted for a rear locker and compressor, it represents a good solution for me.
iver
20th July 2014, 01:33 AM
Today I lunched my rear diff doing a decent hill climb in my 2010 with 130, 000km on it
Who in Australia stocks Ashcroft diff parts??
n plus one
20th July 2014, 06:37 AM
Today I lunched my rear diff doing a decent hill climb in my 2010 with 130, 000km on it
Who in Australia stocks Ashcroft diff parts??
Les Richmond Automotive in Melbourne. They're good on freighting too.
Let us know what let go - I'm assuming C&P?
iver
20th July 2014, 11:11 AM
Im assuming the crown and pinion have been damaged, still drives just howls on over/run. And metalic particles in oil
voltron
20th July 2014, 03:16 PM
Today I lunched my rear diff doing a decent hill climb in my 2010 with 130, 000km on it
Who in Australia stocks Ashcroft diff parts??
hope I haven't jinxed you:(
frantic
20th July 2014, 05:34 PM
Im assuming the crown and pinion have been damaged, still drives just howls on over/run. And metalic particles in oil
The other option is order it yourself from ashcroft, axles,crownwheel pinion and a difflock.
I saw another def owner got the lot in the centre housing pegged, all he had to do was replace rear axles/flanges and cvs on front.
n plus one
20th July 2014, 06:18 PM
The other option is order it yourself from ashcroft, axles,crownwheel pinion and a difflock.
I saw another def owner got the lot in the centre housing pegged, all he had to do was replace rear axles/flanges and cvs on front.
I did that with my front (ATB) and have just ordered a rear (locker) as well - complete third members with HD C&P, pegged, etc.
Quick change out and you have a spare to play with = win!
Homestar
20th July 2014, 07:51 PM
Plough!! They're awesome! I have one at either end and they're currently withstanding 200hp and 5.9 litres of Cummins Turbo Diesel... Know where my choice would be!! ;)
And you can de plough them a bit with a grinder. :), and running 36" tyres helps a lot too. :D
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.4 Copyright © 2025 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.