PDA

View Full Version : Local and Social media - misbehaviour



digger
12th October 2015, 03:00 AM
I am very peeved at the moment and I hope I can explain why..
Let me first advise of the circumstances:-

Last Tuesday we had the unpleasant task of attending a MVA at an intersection on the edge of town where a young lad lost his life.

I was off duty so attended with CFS as part of road rescue/fire crew (driving second truck so fill in whichever may have been required). Unfortunately as I said a young man misjudged the distance of an oncoming b double and pulled across in front of it (less than 45 metres away travelling at 80k) wearing the impact directly on the drivers door and B pillar of his small station wagon. He was killed instantly as the car was ripped almost in two, the B pillar ripped completely away and he was thrown from the car to the roadway. An incredibly harsh penalty to a young bloke for one seconds misjudgement.

For those who don't know, once someone at the scene is declared life extinct or injured severely and likely or possibly going to die , strict evidence rules apply to the scene and everything in it.

That means once anyone alive is removed from the scene and the scene is rendered safe by attending services, then everything else must be left in situ, this includes the deceased. Obviously what needs to be covered is covered as soon as possible and the scene is preserved.

This was all done, the passenger (injured ) was removed to hospital, the poor truck driver also taken to hospital for checks -(obviously he was in shock)
the deceased was covered, car, scene and truck all cordoned off with cones and traffic directed around the whole intersection.

Major Crash Investigation Section attended about 2.5 hrs later (pretty good as we are almost 2 hours from their base in ADELAIDE.) and after the initial examination of the scene and the deceased he was removed from the scene.

About 7 hours after we first attended we packed up and headed back to the station.

OK here is where/why I have my goat up...

On arrival back at the station we were told that the whole scene had been photographed prior to the arrival of emergency services and posted on facebook immediately! This included pictures of the deceased lad lying on the roadway!

I find this unbelievable, obviously the next of kin had no idea their son had been in a collision let alone that he was dead but there it all was posted up on social bloody media! (bastards!)

To compound this, the local paper have a long standing agreement with emergency services where they have access to a scene (eg: in the emergency services cordon- not the actual scene) to take photographs etc for their job. There is a briefing every year for this where it is stressed that there is no photos to include injured (without permission) or deceased or contaminated areas (eg blood stain/splatter pool etc etc)- along with training for safety etc (as scenes includes fires/ accidents etc etc)

The paper have attended the scene and been directed to a clearing to park before reporting to the group officer and the Police officer in charge of the scene to be advised and to take their photos. They have taken photographs from this point, showing the car and the blood stained blanket covering the deceased. Even worse they've taken video of the scene and then focussed on the car and the bloody blanket over the deceased lad.

Making this worse (as if it could be!) they've then led with a photograph on their front page showing the devastated car and the blanket over the deceased (but thankfully it doesn't show the blood staining).

They have then (just to make sure the town has exploded in anger against them) posted the video they took to their facebook site! The protests have been thick and fast and now they've edited the video so it shows the scene etc and the sheet over the body but cuts before they fully focus in like it was originally posted but left the rest online!!

Then they've written their story naming a local as being first on scene (she wasn't - she was probably 5th or 6th), and saying it occurred directly outside her business (thats 200 metres down the road) and giving three quotes allegedly from her (all of which she not only denies but is incredibly mad about).

So my beef (I hope) is obvious.

Why do people not realise that they are putting stuff out into the ether and out on the newspaper front page where everyone, friends, and relatives of those involved may see?
And why does it need to be shown to people who try not to think about this stuff as it disturbs them or brings back memories of others lost?

While I am at it,
what the hell makes someone think its OK to slow down and stare or even worse VIDEO on their phones etc the scene as they pass??
what kind of ghoul does that???

What 'knob" then "likes" that and or "shares" it??

I am increasingly disappointed by people now days when we are at scenes. Its amazing how many people need to take their dog for a walk at 2am and loiter around the edge of the scene of serious accidents etc...

The collision occurred at a cross road across a major highway and the day after the long weekend ended (and as such because the school holidays were on, many delayed their travel until the tuesday trying to avoid the traffic but instead moving it from Monday to Tuesday.)

People still, even with fire trucks, police cars etc placed across roads and cones and detour signs etc erected seem to believe that:
a) the detour/road closed sign doesn't apply to them or that
b) they can barter their way around the signs with whomever is manning the point !
c) a few even drove through the cones trying to cross through the scene, these were stopped (one nearly ran over a firey) they were then issued fines for entering the scene and had to supply a statement to be delivered to the coroner by being included in the coronors file which is prepared. In that statement they are required to state why they entered the scene.
d) recently (at another serious collision/fatal) we had the road closed, a rescue chopper sitting in the middle of the highway being loaded and a bozo decided to try and drive through!! Needless to say he left his car on the side of the road until bail was granted.


Anyway I am very disappointed with elements of the community and now you know why...


(on the other side of this there are a lot of people who shine at these moments and as a result of them by going way beyond anything expected of them and to those I am eternally greatful for and to them )

anyway Rant Over...:eek:. thanks!

V8Ian
12th October 2015, 03:37 AM
I can empathise with you and the tragic situation Digger.
A couple of years ago I was held up on the Bruce Highway, along with a considerable amount of other light and heavy traffic, following a fatal incident. Similarly, on last day of school holidays, at 2am a woman in a 4x4 station wagon with a number of kids, left the road and rolled multiple times. All were injured, a young boy fatally. I was appalled at some of the callous comments and complaints by a minority of held up motorists. The threats of violence and expressions of anger from some of the 'rough, tough' truckies was applauded.
Another time, as an SES member, we had to attend a light plane crash on a road. It was amazing how many vehicles had to drive back and forth, multiple times through the contraflow.
Many of the public seem to totally lack respect for these poor victims. Would they appreciate a little privacy and consideration if it were them in the situation?
Look after yourself Digger.

Chops
12th October 2015, 07:00 AM
I empathize with the friends and relatives of the young man.

Years ago, I woke to a radio report that my best mate had been shot and killed. It's got to be THE worst way of finding out this type of information. His wife was distraught that she couldn't get to tell me before it went to air.

Keep up the good work Nigel, I feel for you mate.

trog
12th October 2015, 07:06 AM
people are ghouls, whatever the form of media. Television for example do not need to endlessly loop the scenes of an incident to show the "emotion". I would have thought good journalism would convey the image tactfully and tastefully with words.

TerryO
12th October 2015, 07:41 AM
On a different tack but also relating to ghoulish behaviour at road accidents I have a habit of turning on the two way when I come across a traffic jam on the freeway, so I can get an idea if the traffic is actually moving or how long the delay might be.

On a number of occasions I have heard truck drivers cursing the police and rescue services for taking so long to open the road. Some of the insulting and insensitive crap I have heard makes me wonder what kind of low life scum some of these people are.

No wonder the police hound truckies because they to would be listening to this discusting bile filled moronic rubbish that some of them blurt out.

By the way Digger thank you for being one of those selfless people who go out and assist at these tragic and often horrific scenes. I for one could not do that kind of job, again thank you.

flyinglandrover
12th October 2015, 07:52 AM
You are right on the money Digger! I am sure the social media thing is just to be able to say they were there or first to post details! Just shows how pathetic some of these people are. Will there be any repercussions to the social media poster? You would hope so!
Keep your head down and take care

DAMINK
12th October 2015, 08:10 AM
Very sad for the families this one i have to say first of all!
But this plays out daily in a variety of ways and has for a very long time.

How many people could drive past a road accident and not slow down to look?
Every accident i have passed this is common. Well not common this is standard practice. Does not make it right but it does happen.

liveleaks or the old ogorish is a good example.
There are a lot of people who enjoy watching others get hurt or even die.
Remember the beheadings, they were very popular videos on the web.

Where does one draw the line i have to ask.
We see Allied planes dropping bombs from miles away killing people every day on the news. Sure we dont see the blood and guts (unless you go to places like liveleaks) but we do see the devastation and can imagine the carnage within.
Fundamental difference there is its murder instead of an accident.

The public must enjoy watching it or the press would not play it.
Or perhaps its desensitization of the public we are seeing play out.

Just my take on the situation.

Sad as the situation may be.

digger
12th October 2015, 08:12 AM
Thanks guys,

Terry we have found the opposite, that is when we have a road closure or delay the truckies pretty much self regulate, we had a truck move his vehicle across the roadway blocking both lanes (diagonal trailers) and when we asked why he told us he was pretty upset when he saw people trying to get through while we were cutting away at the cars!! So he made it a no choice situation for them.

Other truckies also hound down any that get too out of line especially on the radio, its suprising how many are either current or ex emergency services.

There is one particular company however who are likely to be stopped each time when we are doing traffic stop/go each end after the collision the other day, they were making sport of how many traffic cones they could run over on their way through. Besides messing our cones up (they were clipping them not crushing them, it got to us because we could hear them on the uhf keeping score, so each one of that company got stopped and asked individually not to bowl the cones, all bar one asked didnt run them over...

(that all being said its relatively harmless and no one was put in any danger etc by this "game!)

Roverlord off road spares
12th October 2015, 08:15 AM
You would think with all the shock and horror it would change people's attitudes on how to behave on the roads, but it doesn't.
People have become to blase and complacent .
:mad:

p38arover
12th October 2015, 08:21 AM
By the way Digger thank you for being one of those selfless people who go out and assist at these tragic and often horrific scenes. I for one could not do that kind of job, again thank you.

It's not often I agree with Terry, but I certainly do so here!

Bushie
12th October 2015, 08:27 AM
It doesn't seem that much has really changed, especially from the media perspective, except the methods of transmission and publication have changed.
Nearly 40 years ago I remember a news helicopter over us broadcasting details pretty much live to air that virtually identified those involved.
Copper at the scene did 'offer' to shoot it down.

The younger generations nowadays though seem to live their lives via facebook, instagram, etc so I think it's a case of - rather than saying "we went past a bad accident on the way here" its post to some form of social media. There may not be any intent to cause grief, just no thought!


Martyn

DAMINK
12th October 2015, 08:36 AM
It doesn't seem that much has really changed, especially from the media perspective, except the methods of transmission and publication have changed.
Nearly 40 years ago I remember a news helicopter over us broadcasting details pretty much live to air that virtually identified those involved.
Copper at the scene did 'offer' to shoot it down.

The younger generations nowadays though seem to live their lives via facebook, instagram, etc so I think it's a case of - rather than saying "we went past a bad accident on the way here" its post to some form of social media. There may not be any intent to cause grief, just no thought!


Martyn

I think a lot of the time its the 5 minutes of fame problem.
So many people want there 5 minutes and will do just about anything to get it.
First to upload a video, even if its bad may offer them this.
Last thing i would do is pull out my phone. Hell i would likely jump out of the car and offer assistance if i could.
But thats the world we live. Everyone wants there 5 minutes.

debruiser
12th October 2015, 08:41 AM
On a different tack but also relating to ghoulish behaviour at road accidents I have a habit of turning on the two way when I come across a traffic jam on the freeway, so I can get an idea if the traffic is actually moving or how long the delay might be.

I've started doing this as well. More so I can decide if I should just turn around and go back to where I came from - help keep the area somewhat clear. If I decide to wait, then I do my best not to look around and just drive through safely when directed.

On the social media topic - that is disgusting that someone would post images of any accident, I certainly don't want to see any of that and I really can't believe that someone would take photos not to mention share those. Personally I would have reported those posts.


By the way Digger thank you for being one of those selfless people who go out and assist at these tragic and often horrific scenes. I for one could not do that kind of job, again thank you.

Here here. Couldn't agree more! I would never be able to do that job... I take my hat off to anyone who chooses to do this.

Eevo
12th October 2015, 09:00 AM
as a fellow cfs member, i fully sympathise with you digger. people are idiots at the best of times and they seems to swam on the roads.

i hate to be the bad guy in this instance, i think that as the crash happened on a public road, any photos are public domain. so taking photos and putting them on facebook, although a low act, isnt wrong. it might be against facebooks terms n conditions.

the media are mongrels. would sell their own mother to get a story.

bushie: please dont paint every young person with the same brush. i'm under 30 and dont use facebook or social media.

Tombie
12th October 2015, 09:59 AM
Digger...

Its been a long time since I've had to deal with a fatality scene and I certainly am not in any rush to attend one again in any capacity.

Just like to say I take my hat of to people such as yourself who have the responsibility of dealing with these events... The community owe you a debt of gratitude.

Keep doing the fantastic work you do mate. I for one appreciate it.

incisor
12th October 2015, 10:58 AM
you can't alter human nature...

you might restrain it or suppress it but as soon as the chance presents people revert...

the likes of facebook, google, twitter and instagram etc etc base their business model on it just as the operators of the Colosseum did...

sad fact of life unfortunately

DAMINK
12th October 2015, 11:03 AM
I had a mate of mine get in an indecent a few years ago.
He is here right now as i post this!

Big fight, one dead and quite a few injuries.
From his own words it was the ambos and emergency services that were gathering around to talk about it and share in the gore.

How often do you actually think its the first responders that end up posting this stuff online?

vnx205
12th October 2015, 11:48 AM
I wonder how much the recent savage cuts to numbers of staff at regional newspapers has contributed to the poor standard of journalism mentioned in the first post.

DiscoMick
13th October 2015, 01:19 PM
Yep, when I was in the media a long time ago the standard convention was not to show bodies. However, overseas, anything goes.


Agree about the behaviour of some passing motorists. We were first on the scene of a woman who crashed her Toyota and her and the son were trapped in it earlier this year on a road near Coffs. While we were calling in emergency services and trying to slow traffic and help the trapped people there were several drivers who either refused to slow down or who actually pulled up and took photos. I was disgusted.

Disco Muppet
13th October 2015, 01:38 PM
Hmm.
I slow down at crash sites.
So I don't run into the people in front of me, or in case there are still emergency services people moving around.
We passed a (thankfully non fatal) incident a while ago at Mt Victoria in the blue mountains, does tend to leave you fairly shocked so why people would feel the need to go and plaster it on social media is beyond me.
As has been said, Thanks for the work you do digger!

alien
13th October 2015, 02:50 PM
Not far out of our village there is a bridge that was at the time a "Black Spot" location.
A local started a web page to push for the repairs to realign the bridge.

The last accident at the bridge was a truck rollover.
A couple passed after driving into the trailer as it slid along the road.
Before the Accident Investigation Squad where on scene photos had appeared on the web site.
We informed the OIC and the camera, computer and more where seized as evidence .
There was one very unhappy person who had no concern for the feelings of his nearby nehbour who had just lost his parents.
He didn't get much sympathy from those of us in the emergency services when he asked "who told the police?".



Chin up Digger, don't forget peer support etc..
It's encoroging to hear the community backlash at the pictures being aired.
Hopefully this will bring a change for the better.
As for the childish truck drivers driving at the cones, what can I say.
It's more resources but the local van doing a "log book n bretho" just to delay the day(further)with a please explain why you feel it's good to drive over cones may have some effect.

digger
13th October 2015, 10:29 PM
Thanks guys -
and a big thanks to Ian who gave me a call just to make sure I was "OK MATE".. I do appreciate it big fella!

I am still a bit peeved but venting like I did here helps me a lot (thanks...and sorry) I just keep hearing the horror stories of how people who would normally
first find out when they open the door to a few solemn faced coppers
are now getting "my condolences mrs *** , XXX was a great guy its terrible the way he died" type messages on facebook and thats how they find out!

As for stress I am lucky in that I am in a job where I am given the opportunity by assorted "norberts" to "de-stress" myself by removing them from circulation or delaying their natural habits (which normally are very unnatural) and this has been a big help over the years.

I also have 30 years of this as a job and a reasonable swag of volunteering so have found my way to cope.. Everyone is different. I tend to make sure that there is someone working with any 'new' crew to make sure they are OK.

And I make a point of talking to them one on one both before and after to discuss that which was seen and done.. funnily enough Ive found that the people who I thought were going to be the most vulnerable have been some of the strongest and visa versa.

It is also stressed by everyone to ALL crew that if you need to step away, then just let someone know and go, you can leave at anytime to "check the cones" (thats the code words our crews use). And if it suits go and man the STOP /SLOW sign or just move off for a smoke or a break. Sometimes that 10 minutes is all someone needs to get 'their head in the right place" and they are back in!

The main thing I believe (and preach to my poor children!) is that if you live somewhere and want someone to come if you have an accident or you have a fire etc, then you need to do it for others- sort of building your own "rainy day points" if you like. Same applies with being part of sports clubs and Lions club (or rotary or whichever is your choice) its all if you want it to happen in your patch you need to be involved at some point to do it.

The mates I have made, across all ages, races, religions, both sexes and all types have been brilliant! And they are indeed mates not just acquaintances.
I suggest anyone thinking about it jump in, there are always spots.

And the traffic cones? I think its a game to them and so long an noone is hurt or in danger of being hurt, its not a problem! (but keep your logbooks up lads :twisted: )

On the upside, I get to drive the BBWFT or the BSNWRT !
Or even our BOVFT :)

*
BBWFT = BLOODY BIG WHITE FIRE TRUCK
BSNWRT = BLOODY SLOW NEW WHITE RESCUE TRUCK
BOVFT = BLOODY OLD VINTAGE FIRE TRUCK*

weeds
13th October 2015, 10:41 PM
I slow down......common sense

I also have a look......hard not to, human nature

Both of the above to see if my help is needed.....

Although I wouldn't dream of taking photos and posting online.

Tough gig for anybody responding to accidents......take my hat off to you guys.

Bytemrk
13th October 2015, 11:08 PM
Take my hat off to you Digger, to cope with the amount of this stuff your main job dredges up is not easy for anyone. To go round regularly for an extra dose with the volunteer work is above and beyond.

I can totally understand your frustration and need to vent...it makes me smile though to see the calibre of replies you got here.

A little reminder that some of humanity is still ok ;)