What to buy D4 Tdv6 2.7 or D4 tdv6 3.0

[Zedrover]

Hi guys ,

Please help yes still trying to work out the best option it is down to 2
Tdv6 2009 2.7L 140,000 Klms
With satnav with new model interior
- am I right in thinking that they would have worked out most of the issues by now in the 2.7 meaning it may be more reliable option?

Or

Tdv6 SE 2010 3.0L 160,000klms
With sat Nav with new model interior
Stories of the 3 L inlet manifold cracking is scaring me a little bit?
But more power newer engine?

please help?

Zedrover

[TerryO]

Yes the D3 was very sorted by 2009 and a very nice bit of kit.

A D4 SE, even a early one, is a far superior vehicle on a number of fronts but yes your correct it sounds like the early ones are starting to have some potential big dollar issues.

Both of the Disco's you have listed are coming up for belts soon so factor in a couple of thousand in maintenance for either.

[rar110]

I'm betting the 2010 SE will have more options than the the 2.7. If they are the same money with equally good service history I would go the 3.0. I'd be getting it serviced every 10,000km from now on.

If having 18" tyres for off road work is really important then if all else is equal I would consider the 2.7, as LR 18" rims won't fit the 3.0.

As said above you will have belts due on both, if not already done.

[Graeme]

If having 18" tyres for off road work is really important then if all else is equal I would consider the 2.7, as LR 18" rims won't fit the 3.0. Budget for 4 Compomotive/GOE 18" rims and 1 or 2 D3/D4 18" rims for spares.

[Catmatt]

Budget for 4 Compomotive/GOE 18" rims and 1 or 2 D3/D4 18" rims for spares.

I was fortunate to buy my 2.7 D4 with a set of extra Compomotive alloy rims. I wouldn't recommend them to anyone as 2 of the rims have developed cracks through the alloy 'spokes'.

After a lot of searching for a welder who would do the job, I had 1 repaired and use it strictly as a spare but now another has cracked....

I do a lot of dirt road driving and exploring but nothing extreme at all and am very surprised that they are cracking.

The alloy welder said that he thought the first cracked rim was due to a stress fracture and once it cracked and relieved the stress, should be all OK...perhaps the 2nd rim is suffering the same 'stress'??

Apart from that hiccup - a great all round car!!

[LRD414]

I was fortunate to buy my 2.7 D4 with a set of extra Compomotive alloy rims. I wouldn't recommend them to anyone as 2 of the rims have developed cracks through the alloy 'spokes'.
You just gave me a mild heart attack but I think you mean "Performance" rims as per your thread last year:
http://www.aulro.com/afvb/d3-d4-rrs/220787-performance-rims.html

I've not heard of any issues with the Compomotive, except for someone damaging one on impact with a tree stump.
http://www.aulro.com/afvb/d3-d4-rrs/229624-bfg-ko2-265-65-18-d4-2.html (last post)

Cheers,
Scott

[Graeme]

And why would anyone buy Compomotive rims for a 2.7 when LR 18" fit?

[BobD]

One of mine cracked through the bead area of the rim but I think it got hit with something. We had it welded up and use it for a spare. I also got a chain saw adjusting screw driver through the tyre and the inner part of the rim when I ran over it at Litchfield National Park and it flicked up through the rear tyre. It was the same rim and that was what caused me to get it all welded up after Gordon told me who could do it in Perth.

[Catmatt]

And why would anyone buy Compomotive rims for a 2.7 when LR 18" fit?

17" after market rims.....good choice of off-road 17" tyres and I can knock them around driving off-road.

18" LR rims.....good choice of 18" road tyres and I keep the rims pristine without being knocked around off-road

Easy peasy!

[Catmatt]

You just gave me a mild heart attack but I think you mean "Performance" rims as per your thread last year:
http://www.aulro.com/afvb/d3-d4-rrs/220787-performance-rims.html

I've not heard of any issues with the Compomotive, except for someone damaging one on impact with a tree stump.
http://www.aulro.com/afvb/d3-d4-rrs/229624-bfg-ko2-265-65-18-d4-2.html (last post)

Cheers,
Scott

Yes you are absolutely right and I stand corrected. It is the "Performance" alloy rims that are giving me grief and NOT the Compomotive rims. (I misread the wheel centre that says "Complete" performance not Compomotive performance).

My mate has a 3.0l D4 with Compomotive rims and they are good quality and look great on his vehicle