Which video do you like best?

[walker]

Some of you will have seen the first video I did today of our trip on Saturday. My wife and and a couple of others have told me they don't like it because it jumps around a lot. I was just trying to be a bit "arty" and get it all in time to the music using clips in random order.

So now I have done another 3 min video which uses the same music but is edited in a more normal way using all the clips in sequence.

Which one do you like better? (you will probably need broadband to view)

<span style="color:red">These links have been deleted, see further down in the thread for video link</span>

Option1 - http://www.zippyvideos.com/940001612452562.../walkers_tk_06/ (http://www.zippyvideos.com/9400016124525626/walkers_tk_06/)

Option2 - http://www.zippyvideos.com/272170054452832...walkers_tk_061/ (http://www.zippyvideos.com/2721700544528326/walkers_tk_061/)


PS. after watching them, if you go to your "temporary internet folder" you can then open them using Windows media and watch it in full screen

[HangOver]

the clips in time with the music idea was good but I think there was a few too many quick scene changes, the random order got me confused, I'm getting old.

to sum up the second one, but changing scene on a beat is good.

[Redback]

I liked them both, but i thought the second one was a bit better to watch because of the less scene changes, it also downloaded faster, not that it was a bad thing but could be for those without cable.

Looked like heaps of fun https://www.aulro.com/afvb/

[Ace]

I only got time to watch the first half of the first one but i reckon you did a pretty good job. Matt

[VladTepes]

Originally posted by downundersteve
the clips in time with the music idea was good but I think there was a few too many quick scene changes, the random order got me confused, I'm getting old.

to sum up the second one, but changing scene on a beat is good.

I agree. I would also note however that I personally would have chosen a different piece of music for that sort of trip - perhaps such a 'beat' might be better for a rock crawling video or something like that.

Yes the idea of synch with the beat is interesting but the rapidity of it was a bit much. If you had more footage and you could change scenes with the beat to a limited extent, and still keep the story line fairly linear I reckon that would be ideal.

Having said that, I have done nothing half as good, so congratulations on both efforts :!: https://www.aulro.com/afvb/



Oh, and I'm jealous - I want lockers and mud :!: :!:

[disco_ute]

I liked both.... but the second one captured the moment a bit better....

Mick

[walker]

Thanks everyone, Option 2 it is then.

When I watched them myself one after the other...even I liked Option 2 better. 8)

[Farnarkle]

Both were pretty good although I prefer the second one

[walker]

Thanks for all the feedback. I wont try to be "arty" ever again. https://www.aulro.com/afvb/

I have modified the video and this one should suit everyone. 8)

http://www.zippyvideos.com/243393970454552...walkers_tk_062/ (http://www.zippyvideos.com/2433939704545526/walkers_tk_062/)

[disco95]

Well I don't know about the others but the last one's pretty good. https://www.aulro.com/afvb/

[RR5L]

Well done, I hope to see a few more of those comming our way in the future.

[Ace]

Yep it gets my vote. Matt

[VladTepes]

Originally posted by walker
Thanks for all the feedback. I wont try to be "arty" ever again. :lol:

I have modified the video and this one should suit everyone. 8)
http://www.zippyvideos.com/2433939704545526/walkers_tk_062/

Wow. That one's heaps good :!:


What video editing program are you using :?:

[walker]

Thanks. https://www.aulro.com/afvb/ https://www.aulro.com/afvb/

I am using Pinnacle Studio 9 Pro.

I also have Adobe Premier which is a lot more powerful but I find Studio a lot easier to use and it's a lot cheaper

[disco_ute]

windows movie maker is pretty good and it's free with xp!!

adobe premier is hardcore!! not for the average user!!


i have read good reports on Microsoft Digital Image Suite 2006 meant to kick ass

Mick

[walker]

I have used all those programs. I don't think Winows movie maker is even comparable with the other programs, it is like comparing a Lada to a new Rangie. https://www.aulro.com/afvb/

But all the others are good, I just find Studio the most user friendly. The earlier versions of Studio had lots of annoying bugs which caused a lot of frustration but they seem to have it all together in version 9 and now version 10 is out.

[disco_ute]

wmm is a toy but for a 1st timer it's easy as pie to use !!

yeah the early versions were bug city!!