Amazingly funny..

[DirtyDawg]

I bought a 12000lb winch of of ebay for a total of $370 including the $75 freight. on its first outting I believed to had thought it had shed a tooth or two as it would pull then go slack and free spin.. quite cheesed off I contacted the supplier who said "stiff" No warranty given, more complaining and he said he would contact manufacturer.answer was sorry but stiff again..
I did some investigating and sent him a personally addressed letter to his home address saying if I didn't get a replacement I would personally return the winch with some KY gel if you get the drift;) Well with the shock of him realizing I knew his name and his home address he said he would send a replacement and he did (3 weeks later) I asked him where he wanted me to send the bust one and he said keep it.
I put the new one in today and dismantled the broke one to see what was wrong.. all that was wrong was a plastic washer which separates the planetary gears had dislodgeds and jammed up in a tooth groove causing the gear to derail a Millimetre or so causing the free spin... removed said plastic, replace washer, repacked with grease, tested it and works like a charm.... So now I have 2 x 12000lb winchs, cables, hooks, remotes and battery leads all for $370......alls well that ends well...

[Mick-Kelly]

So when are you sending me my free winch :p

[DEFENDERZOOK]

you can fit one on the back as well.......

[Frenchie]

you can fit one on the back as well.......

Beat me to it. :D

[solmanic]

It makes you wonder what price the seller is actually buying them for if he is prepared to send out a replacement and let a "busted" one go without any investigation.

[Frenchie]

It makes you wonder what price the seller is actually buying them for if he is prepared to send out a replacement and let a "busted" one go without any investigation.

It also makes you wonder how robust they are and whether they will really pull 12000lb.

A Warn 9000lb winch won't pull anything like 9000lb (which is probably a good thing because the cables they come with are only rated to 8000lb :eek: ).

[adm333]

It makes you wonder what price the seller is actually buying them for if he is prepared to send out a replacement and let a "busted" one go without any investigation.

Well what price do you put on avoiding a 12000 lb winch being coated in KY Jelly and placed uncomfortably.......:eek:

[dobbo]

Good to hear of your fortunate situation yet again Dawg. But remind me never to sell you anything!!!!!!
Just out of interest. when you were going to lube up the winch, were you going to do the right thing and give the bloke a reach around at the same time?

Think about it, if you did it the bloke could come out of the dunny and honestly say that he should get a job as a cable layer;)

[Captain_Rightfoot]

Well what price do you put on avoiding a 12000 lb winch being coated in KY Jelly and placed uncomfortably.......:eek:
Then, you could sell the xrays from the hospital to the paper :eek: :eek:

[Pedro_The_Swift]

It constantly amazes me what you guys expect for **** bought off ebay,,

the main(if not the ONLY reason) they sell stuff there is so they can GET AWAY with it,,






or so I thought----:unsure:

[Blknight.aus]

the bad news is hes going to have to wait till october to get his cable to wire it up....

or you know twas the season.....

(big reds looking for a nice little winch you know ) :P


good deals dude...

[DirtyDawg]

the bad news is hes going to have to wait till october to get his cable to wire it up....

or you know twas the season.....

(big reds looking for a nice little winch you know ) :P


good deals dude...
You still here dave or have you gone back to the Border town?

[Tank]

It also makes you wonder how robust they are and whether they will really pull 12000lb.

A Warn 9000lb winch won't pull anything like 9000lb (which is probably a good thing because the cables they come with are only rated to 8000lb :eek: ).
It makes me Wonder why the Governments of Australia allow ALL of these winch manufacturers (Warn included) to advertise and sell their winches stating the Guaranteed Breaking Stain (GBS) of the cable supplied. The Safe Working Load (SWL) or the Working Load (WL) which should have a Safety Factor (SF) of around 6 (GBS divided by SF e.g. 12000 divided by 6) should be the advertised strength of the winch and cable. A simple calculation for wire cable strength is Dia. Squared and Multiplied by 10, i.e. 10mm cable (six strand) Galvanised wire would be 10x10x10 = 1000klgs. SWL for winch wire which is (or should be to stop crushing) 7 strand and sometimes High Tensile you can add about 20 to 30% more. Most winches are the same gearwise and motorwise, it is the strength of the cable that determines it's capacity, i.e. 12000lbs (GBS), but if you work to the GBS you are asking for trouble, I think it is extremely dangerous and wrong, the way winches are advertised, Regards Frank.

[Tank]

I bought a 12000lb winch of of ebay for a total of $370 including the $75 freight. on its first outting I believed to had thought it had shed a tooth or two as it would pull then go slack and free spin.. quite cheesed off I contacted the supplier who said "stiff" No warranty given, more complaining and he said he would contact manufacturer.answer was sorry but stiff again..
I did some investigating and sent him a personally addressed letter to his home address saying if I didn't get a replacement I would personally return the winch with some KY gel if you get the drift;) Well with the shock of him realizing I knew his name and his home address he said he would send a replacement and he did (3 weeks later) I asked him where he wanted me to send the bust one and he said keep it.
I put the new one in today and dismantled the broke one to see what was wrong.. all that was wrong was a plastic washer which separates the planetary gears had dislodgeds and jammed up in a tooth groove causing the gear to derail a Millimetre or so causing the free spin... removed said plastic, replace washer, repacked with grease, tested it and works like a charm.... So now I have 2 x 12000lb winchs, cables, hooks, remotes and battery leads all for $370......alls well that ends well...
Dirty Dawg, it would be wise to repack with a Good quality Waterproof grease your freebie as the melted down "soap" the Chinese call grease will only hasten the demise of the roughly cut gear sets, also have a look at the collar that the gear change lever goes through, mine was only pressed in and soon came loose and fell out of the gear housing, I stripped mine down an welded this collar in, it's a lot quieter with some decent Real grease as well, Regards Frank.

[Jamo]

I put Dynamica rope on mine. It's rated to toyota an nissan:p . I don't know about Land Rovers as they don't need to be recovered.:D

(But I really only have it for pose value)

[RichardK]

It also makes you wonder how robust they are and whether they will really pull 12000lb.

A Warn 9000lb winch won't pull anything like 9000lb (which is probably a good thing because the cables they come with are only rated to 8000lb :eek: ).

The very reason why I run a hydraulic winch, which comes with much stronger wire rope than the ARB's.
That's my next project.......get it running in the D3

[RobHay]

I bought a 12000lb winch of of ebay for a total of $370 including the $75 freight. on its first outting I believed to had thought it had shed a tooth or two as it would pull then go slack and free spin.. quite cheesed off I contacted the supplier who said "stiff" No warranty given, more complaining and he said he would contact manufacturer.answer was sorry but stiff again..
I did some investigating and sent him a personally addressed letter to his home address saying if I didn't get a replacement I would personally return the winch with some KY gel if you get the drift;) Well with the shock of him realizing I knew his name and his home address he said he would send a replacement and he did (3 weeks later) I asked him where he wanted me to send the bust one and he said keep it.
..

Geeeeezzzzzzz....Hate to sell you some pineapples.:eek: