PDA

View Full Version : GU Series 1 98 Vs Discovery Series 2 99



HAK
2nd July 2007, 10:02 AM
Hi all

Some of you are aware that Sam D and I went to the wattgans yesterday so I’m doing a personal comparesent between my last 4wd 98 GU Series 1 against my current 4wd 99 Discovery Series 2 both petrol, GU obviously being 4.5 6 cylinder and rover V8 4.0 litre the GU being manual the rover being Automatic

I found that the rover V8 and gearing was way superior to that of the Patrol however the clearance of the diff center was my D2 biggest let down however this can be fixed, I am running 50% tread on standard road michellens so what more could one expect, on the same token the GU always got caught up in the middle part of chassis

The goodies such as the ACE, Hill Decent and traction control all played a important part of the off road experience however I didn’t really tackle hard obstacles due to the D2 being so standard well I did one which left me stranded on the diff centers after falling into a rutt which left Sam to break out his virgin recovery gear

I deflated one wheel of the rim nearly ripped of the front bumper and placed a million scratches on the British racing green paint job

Some one on the forum suggest I get out there and have a feel for what I need as far as mods

In conclusion I think a lift of greater then 2 inch is needed and wheels of at least 33 inch would be desirable

Rayngie
2nd July 2007, 10:20 AM
That's interesting.

I'm currently driving a 2006 GU 4.8 petrol Semi-auto, compared to the Discovery is a whole different world of comfort.

scared to take it offroad tho....looks to good at the moment.

Ray

mcrover
2nd July 2007, 01:24 PM
That's interesting.

I'm currently driving a 2006 GU 4.8 petrol Semi-auto, compared to the Discovery is a whole different world of comfort.

scared to take it offroad tho....looks to good at the moment.

Ray

School buses are always pretty comfy.....

HAK
2nd July 2007, 02:50 PM
That's interesting.

I'm currently driving a 2006 GU 4.8 petrol Semi-auto, compared to the Discovery is a whole different world of comfort.

scared to take it offroad tho....looks to good at the moment.

Ray

My old man own 04 GU 3.0 Desiel his complaint was the same how ever disco is way smaller then potrol

he wont drive it off road hell he bearly drives it its got 11000km

loanrangie
2nd July 2007, 02:55 PM
School buses are always pretty comfy.....

School buses handle better though !

Outlaw
2nd July 2007, 03:19 PM
easy solution... Mog portals under the disco.

or slightly cheaper alternative... GU diffs under it

HAK
2nd July 2007, 04:54 PM
easy solution... Mog portals under the disco.

or slightly cheaper alternative... GU diffs under it


Whats a Mog portal

loanrangie
2nd July 2007, 04:57 PM
Whats a Mog portal

Mercedes Unimog which has drop boxes on the axles giving great under diff clearance.

HAK
3rd July 2007, 07:13 AM
Mercedes Unimog which has drop boxes on the axles giving great under diff clearance.


Oh the Unimog

mcrover
3rd July 2007, 08:34 AM
School buses handle better though !

Depends on whats done to it and if Ive got air in my tyres.....

My Disco handles heaps better than my mate GU and another mates GQ and my old 80 series on both dirt and the road but I suppose with road tyres and no lift then it probably could keep up lol lol lol.

It would lose me in the straights though, in that it would leave me well behind while I peak out at 135kmh.

Pootrols are just 4wd school busses that are kinda capable off road but the score so far for me is Pootrols 3, Landcruisers 2 landrovers 2, my own once with my winch.

My mates pootrol GQ has snatched me once when I ran out of diff clearance before I had the bigger tyres.

And Mine isnt highly modified just a susp lift and tyres which are AT's.

I do stress about muddy hills though...

rick130
3rd July 2007, 11:55 AM
tyre diameter for tyre diameter, Rover diffs have better clearance than Nissan, but strength is a different matter entirely.......

mcrover
3rd July 2007, 12:06 PM
Landrovers also have a weight advantage, length and width advantage and all landies are better looking as are most of their owners, except me.

Cameron_Def
3rd July 2007, 12:14 PM
I find this funny

As if someone who owns a Disco / Defender etc will ever let something else sound better.

Its like asking ford reps to get holden a car review .. its never going to beat what we own :)

Ever!

Ace
3rd July 2007, 12:40 PM
tyre diameter for tyre diameter, Rover diffs have better clearance than Nissan, but strength is a different matter entirely.......

i was about to say the same thing. I was told a disco on 31's has the same diff clearance as a cruiser or pootrol on 33's. This prooved correct when i went out with a cruiser on 33's and didnt get hung up on things he thought i would with the smaller tyres. Infact in alot of places he went through and got hung up, but with some huffing and puffing managed to clear the obstacle, then when i went through i had no problem so maybe he lowered the centre of the rut. Matt