I know what you are saying, that's why I use a spreadsheet/ database arrangement and calculate the results. Over time trends show.
If you get outstanding fuel consumption and the next fill delivers rubbish you can just about guarantee the fill you used to calculate the first figures wasn't filled to the top.
I like to chart the results, showing an overall average and a last 10 fill average. It can often point to a developing problem before something more sinister manifests itself. If your consumption unexpectedly increases (the 10 fill average is climbing) its time to work out why.

