Thread: Where do motoring journo's get off?

Was looking to (possibly) change my D3 for something easier to service in remote area and was checking the Ford, Mazda, Izuzu, Toyota 4WD double cab ute offerings.
Dismissed the idea when I found out that although they have 3+tonne towing capacity they ALL HAVE DRUM BRAKES ON REAR. (so 1960's)
Cannot imagine what driving through mud/water etc would do to drum brakes, but I don't want to find out the hard way.

Originally Posted by vbrab

Was looking to (possibly) change my D3 for something easier to service in remote area and was checking the Ford, Mazda, Izuzu, Toyota 4WD double cab ute offerings.
Dismissed the idea when I found out that although they have 3+tonne towing capacity they ALL HAVE DRUM BRAKES ON REAR. (so 1960's)
Cannot imagine what driving through mud/water etc would do to drum brakes, but I don't want to find out the hard way.

Not only that, they also have horse and cart rear springs, woeful road dynamics, all need suspension upgrades, are woeful to park and unless you're a tradie or farmer the load area is unusable without a canopy (extra $$).

Remote area servicing can be an issue, depending on where you are. It's Land Rovers biggest downfall IMO, it's something you do need to factor into running costs. If they are serious about new Defender they'll need to address poor service outside the cities.

Motoring journos never really cover these type of things, or much else in terms of day to day practicalities of owning one vehicle over another. Most of them pretty much regurgitate the gumf that vehicle manufacturers spin doctors publish.

Drum brakes have been around for way longer than discs and, in most respects, work just as well (in some ways even better). There is no real problem with driving them through water and /or mud, provided that you understand what the potential issues are, and act accordingly. The only issue with water in drum brakes for example, is that you will experience a lack of braking immediately after immersion - but if you drive slowly with your foot pressed lightly on the brake pedal for a few seconds after getting them wet, they will dry out straight away and return to normal performance. Most modern drum brakes do a pretty good job of keeping mud out - but I have filled brake drums with mud more often than I'd care to remember. A simple hose-out after driving through mud has always worked for me.

Leaf springs - well yes, they are a bit harsher to ride on than coils, and definitely don't compare with modern air suspension. But they are designed as a load carrier and, in this respect, nothing beats them. If the ride is a bit harsh, simply throw a bit of weight in the back and the ride is not that bad. Some of the newer utes (eg VW Amarok) offer different rated rear suspension packs (for load carrying or for comfort). The "comfort" option on the VW gives you a softer spring pack and better ride, but at the expense of load carrying capacity. My young bloke's new Amarok has the heavier (standard) load carrying suspension option, and even with this and the back of the ute empty, the ride is no worse than many conventional sedans and wagons that I have owned / travelled in.

As for remote area servicing - this one is a complete furphy. Regardless of which brand of ute you are looking at (except possibly for some of the more recently introduced Chinese & Indian brands which you do not see a lot of anyway) - it is no more difficult to find servicing agents outside of the metropolitan areas than for any Toyota / Holden / Ford - and definitely MUCH more servicing options available than for a modern Land Rover. But even regarding the Land Rovers, the lack of servicing options is nowhere near the "problem" that some people claim. I live in Kalgoorlie where there is no Land Rover distributor / agent / dealership and have owned Land Rovers for at least the past 10 years - never had a problem getting my vehicles serviced or having any necessary repairs completed on them. Parts availability is often no worse than and in many cases better than Toyota. Kalgoorlie has one of the largest Toyota dealerships there is outside of metropolitan areas, and I've lost count of the number of times I've had to wait for even simple basic parts (like a fan belt for a Prado) to be overnighted up from Perth. I can get any parts I need for a Land Rover in at least the same timeframe, and then either fit it myself, or use a local mechanical service I trust to do the work for me.

But I certainly agree with the comments made on here about motoring journo's. Most of them wouldn't know their arse from their elbow.

Originally Posted by BMKal

I've lost count of the number of times I've had to wait for even simple basic parts (like a fan belt for a Prado) to be overnighted up from Perth. I can get any parts I need for a Land Rover in at least the same timeframe, and then either fit it myself, or use a local mechanical service I trust to do the work for me.

Usual business practice these days IMHO. Just in time delivery only. No-one (broad statement I know ) these days keeps anything in stock, even metro businesses don't have everything. My MY13 D4 was built without the trailer harness - no wonder the trailer lights wouldn't work and the dealer had to get one in. Not a common part I know but it is symptomatic of today's economy in that it costs money to hold stock in case someone wants it.

Martin

It's not the wait time on parts that's the issue, with servicing outside cities IME, but the difficulty finding a mechanic who firstly wants to work on a Land Rover and secondly is good at it. Obviously everyone's individual experience will vary on this, but it is certainly a very common experience not to find good service for Land Rovers outside cities, both from my own experience living in northern and remote areas for many years and from the feedback I've had from other Landy owners over many years.

....Even in cities this is why, rightly, so much is made of taking your Landy to an indy who specialises in servicing Landy's. It's just that outside of major centres specialist Landy Indy's are few and far between. It's not like you can take your Land Rover to one of the hundreds of Toyota service centres across the country if you can't find a good indy! It's a massive difference in customer care.

Having said this I'd never trade my Landy for a Toyota, but then I am someone who, while not a mechanic, is confident and capable of fixing many things. Many people simply aren't confident in this area and IMO shouldn't have to be. They should be better supported by the manufacturer of the product they buy when they use it in the places it is intended to be used. To me this all points to the city centric priorities of LRA and explains very simply why you see so few Land Rovers (other than those owned by travellers) living and working across the majority of this huge continent - one of the worlds continents where a 4WD vehicle is actually necessary.

Obviously if you can fix your vehicle yourself none of this matters, but that is beside the point.

PS: IMO Coil Springs are clearly better than drum brakes and leaf springs. Defenders have been carrying massive loads for eons now with coil springs on the rear. And I've lost count how many 70 series Toyotas and Hilux I've pulled out of bogs with my Defender because their leaf springs have grounded the vehicle and/or not allowed enough wheel travel. Disc Brakes are also clearly better than drums, there wouldn't be a performance vehicle on the market with drum brakes! and having to hose them out for them to work properly is just silly, if there is the option of disc brakes.

amongst it's sporty rivals" (despite not even being tested off-road!) and that "I can't help think [sic] this car has been created specifically for cities such as London and Los Angeles..." !!

I am afraid I have to agree with them on that one and of course rich deluded greenies who think that they are saving the earth.

I reckon by far the majority will be sold to London Finance minions who want to not pay the pollution surcharge.
regards Philip A

Originally Posted by MrLandy

To me this all points to the city centric priorities of LRA and explains very simply why you see so few Land Rovers (other than those owned by travellers) living and working across the majority of this huge continent - one of the worlds continents where a 4WD vehicle is actually necessary.

I agree with the thrust of your argument here but this statement is a bit of an over simplification.

It is easy to say they need a bigger service network, but the reality is they need to make money.

To become a manufacturer approved service centre requires a significant investment, both on the part of the manufacturer and of the service centre itself. For this to happen there needs to be a large enough market within that service centre's area to make a worthwhile return on that investment, for no-one will want to make that investment if they can't make a return on it.

The commercial reality is that for LR that market does not exist. Therefore they need to concentrate their resources on where they will get the best return - ie populated areas.

LR are a niche manufacturer and simply do not have the resources available to them that Toyota have. Even if LRA were able to increase their sales tenfold and make a huge dealer network viable, LR simply could not supply them with product.

So the best they can do is concentrate their resources where they will have the most effect and build market share slowly over time. As this builds the demand for service will grow and so more service centres will become viable.

Cheers,
Jon

Some great pragmatic thinking there Jon.

Chicken and egg though too.

Yes it's a shame they gave that market up in the 80's. The road to recovery is long indeed, but the opulence of the brand belies their struggle.

Are you saying JLR are one of the most hard up vehicle manufacturers in the world? not sure I'm convinced of that.

How many years in a row has Disco won best 4x4? And motoring journos are still sucked in by the 'unbreakable' spin. I suggest LR needs to shift its image too, from promoting itself as primarily a purveyor of luxury glorified shopping carts, in order to win the bushability market back that should already be the LR heartland.