Hi landoman, you are not understanding what you are seeing.
Your batteries are NOT holding a charge, they are simply holding a voltage.
Without an applied load, the voltage is irrelevant.
Your SC80 has a known current load and based on that known current load, your batteries are going flat way too quickly, again meaning they are NOT holding a full charge.
My guess is that your batteries are down to around 50% of their full capacity.
To your question and no, do not use the RECONDITION cycle, as it hits the batteries with a 15.8v charge and that is way, WAY to high for any AGM, just use the standard multi stage charging and make sure you put the charger on at night and turn it off each morning, or in reverse if that suits you.
Do not just put the charger on and leave it on for a week as this will not rejuvenate your batteries.

