The OEM Wranglers are really quiet, smooth and very grippy in the wet and dry ... even after a bit of wear. I'm still running a set on my recent D4. They've lasted a lot longer than on my first car, because I have a second set of wheels.
They do have a few cons though IMO ....
- They are or certainly used to be a tad expensive (~$500 a corner when I looked in 2010)... but maybe prudent shopping now would fix that. Just did a quick google search - $315 for the 255/55/19 ... so they have dropped a fair bit since I first looked. Probably more options now .. meaning healthy competition.