
Originally Posted by
whitakerb
Say for example my Rangie is up to its sills in mud and isn't going to go anywhere easily, suggesting as per US Army manual it will need approx 18T of force to remove from the hole
Snatch strap is attached to my Rangie and recovery vehicle with a 3500kg bow shackles.
If the recovery vehicle moves at walking pace and my maths are correct you will apply the following force on your gear.
For the sake of the argument, my Rangie is an immovable object and we are ignoring any other outside forces.
Mass = Recovery vehicle = 2000kg
Velocity = walking pace = 3km/h = 0.833333m/s
F = X KG
X= M*V
= 2000*0.83333 = 1666.66
Force = 1666.66KG
So not too much, but to overload the bow shackles we only need 3500kg of force;
F = 3500
M = 2000
V = F/M
3500/2000
1.75m/s = 6.3KM/H
So again if my maths are correct, you need to be doing 6.3km/h to overload a 3.5 T Bow shackle, however you are not likely to break it due to its safety factor which is IIRC 500% so 17.5T
Not much IMHO
Now say the Reece hitch was fully welded, and rule of thumb is 1 inch of weld will hold 1000kg then:
Reece hitch is 50x50mm = 8 inches of weld = 8000kg breaking strain, were not looking at a great deal of speed to create a lethal object.
If anything, make sure you pack your shovel next time so you can do the walking pace recoverys rather than trying warp speed to 'pop' it out of the bog
So condolences out to the victims family and hopefully it wakes us all up when on the tracks
Bookmarks