Garry (note correct spelling this time)
Often with S1's the reason that springs punch holes in the chassis is because the rubber bushes have gone and the S1 front shackles are too short to prevent the secondary leaf rubbing on the bottom of the chassis. Some people replace the S1 type with S2/S3 shackles which are about 9/16" longer. The problem is that it also makes the angle on the drive shaft more acute and the shaft too short, you also risk bump steer.
Diana

