BROCK OR WHINCUP?

[disco man]

Watching the V8s from tassie today and i was thinking to myself who would win in a race between brock at the peak of his powers or whincup. i know its always hard to compare drivers from different eras but with whincup closing in on brocks most pole positions record i was thinking is he better or is brock still the greatest of all time? What do you guys reckon.

[LandyAndy]

Despite being a Ford fan,I would rate Lowndes in the trio.
Andrew

[discovery39]

Brock,
Lowndes,
Whincup.

[disco man]

Despite being a Ford fan,I would rate Lowndes in the trio.
Andrew

very good call how did i forget lowndes must admit i am a ford fan mate did it **** me off when 888 left ford. my all time hero is dick johnson all lot may disagree with me but the greens tuf was i think one of the toughest looking race cars ever made

[Ean Austral]

Even tho I'm a big fan of Loundes, I would say Whincup over Brock by a whisker and mostly because he has proven himself in both Holden and ford

Loundes very close behind.

Cheers Ean

[lewy]

I find it hard to answer this question having been born and bred in Bathurst, Refuse to have a ford in the shed and lived [somehow] through the seventies.These new kids are very good however.Brock

[pop058]

I find it hard to answer this question having been born and bred in Bathurst, Refuse to have a ford in the shed and lived [somehow] through the seventies.These new kids are very good however.Brock

Sorry to rattle your cage, but Ford owned Landrover from 2000-2008, and you own a 2003 D2A

[disco man]

Ok guys pull me up if i am wrong on this maybe whincup by a whisker mainly because of the strength of the drivers whincup has been up against. the current field of V8 supercar drivers is full of class names like bright, tander, winterbottom, the kelly brothers, ingall, and even his team mate lowndes but he has been the stand out driver for a good part of 6 years. where brock's rivals were not as many i guess his biggest threats were moffat and johnson both class acts but lacked the factory support of brock but 9 wins at the mountain is a record that will be hard to beat maybe never will be

[PAT303]

Like all forms of motor sport there isn't a ''best'' driver but a best driver/team/motor/designer with all thier ducks in a row,take away one element and it doesn't work.All the drivers mentioned are equal at thier peek.. Pat

[disco man]

Like all forms of motor sport there isn't a ''best'' driver but a best driver/team/motor/designer with all thier ducks in a row,take away one element and it doesn't work.All the drivers mentioned are equal at thier peek.. Pat

Ok then same cars, same teams, same conditions who wins? they all cant cross the line at the same time.