I know there are a million threads on recovery points already but I have searched through them to try and find the answer to my question but without success. So, here goes...
I have just got my Ladas Recovery Points (TM) through the post and intend to fit them this weekend. I have seen in this thread that WayneP has successfully installed the same recovery points on his 97 Disco TDi which reassures me that they should fir without problems on my 97 Disco V8 (I'm assuming the chassis is the same!).
From what I can see of the installation WayneP's bullbar is very similar to mine and has mounted the recover points using the same bolts used to hold the bullbar to the chasis.
However, I was going to mount my recovery points on the insde edge of the chassis rail at the 'nut end' (for want of a better description) of the bolt not the outside face next to the 'head end' of the bolt.
I am in no way questioning what WayneP has done or suggesting it is wrong etc. I am just wondering if there is any problems with mounting the recovery point as I had intended?
Is there any benefit in mounting the recovery point:
on the inside of the chassis rail instead of the outside?
at the 'nut' end of the bolt instead of the 'head' end?
Hi Sam - I think there is a difference. From what I understand the shear strength of a bolt is reduced by ~50% at the threaded section, so mounting a recovery point at the head end is far stronger than mounting it at the nut end (where it is threaded).
sam d
I suppose you could turn the bolts around so the nuts are on the other side, or get new longer bolts, I believe the closer to the centre of the vehicle for recovery points the better, I know it is only the thickness of the chassis, but it all helps, I am going to make up a set that go on the inside of the chassis and with the hole for the shackle pin vertical so that the shackle can swivel 180 degrees without placing undue strain on the pins when they are in the horizontal plane, Regards Frank.
Just completed installing a pair of the Ladas' recovery points on my SI Discovery. Everything was fairly straight forward but a couple of adjustments were required...
I had to ream the bolt holes a little in the recovery points to suit the ½" bolts - 30 sec in the drill press and a few minutes with a file on the slotted hole was all that was required.
I had to replace the bolts for the crush cans on the front of the chassis with slightly longer ones. In fact, since the lower bolt is 12mm longer than the upper one, it looks like you could use the lower one in the upper position and fit a new bolt in the lower position (at least 125mm long).
I was able to stretch the front arm for the steering protector out on each side by 10mm to accommodate the recovery points which are now sandwiched between the arm and the chassis. This requires a decent pinch bar to apply enough force to create the gap. Sam I think you might have been concerned about this but pulling the bolt up tight pulls the flattened face of the arm nicely in against the recovery point.
It's worth noting that both bolt holes are tubed within the chassis rail to prevent any risk of crushing the chassis walls together.
The pictures show the finished job on the driver's side from the side and the front.
GrahamH
'65 SIIa 88" Hard-top, Rego DW622, 186 Holden, 4.3 diffs (she's still back in NZ)
'88 4-door Rangie (long gone)
'96 Disco SI 3.9V8i (LPG) Manual (Inspector Rex's kennel)
'03 Disco SII TD5 Auto (the serious camping car)
'15 Disco 4 3.0Lt TDV6 (was a dog-hair free zone - not now!!!)
...
Is there any benefit in mounting the recovery point:
on the inside of the chassis rail instead of the outside?
at the 'nut' end of the bolt instead of the 'head' end?
or does it really make no difference?
Cheers!
To the 1st question, no benefit.
But best on the outside if you use a bridle or the recovery load is angled toward the inside. The tension in the bridle will load the bottom bolt in tension plus shear. The shear capacity of a bolt is reduced if the bolt is also in tension.
To the 2nd question, no benefit.
But not as strong if the bolt threads are in the shear plane. If the bolt is long enough the threads may not be in the shear plane, but you may need thick washers under the nut.
From what I can tell from the pics of these recovery points, the shear load on the lower mounting bolt will be nearly double the load attached to the recovery point (assuming a straight pull and simple statics).
So it is prudent to install and use them so that the bolt threads are not in the shear plane and the angle of the recovery load does not place the lower bolt in tension (except for small recovery loads).
Bookmarks