I went through this whole pinion seal early/late flange and different seal issue not long ago. I hope this can help someone in the future.
Firstly there are four types of seals and two flanges that will fit a LR Salisbury. These are combinations of:
- Original leather seal and original flange - these are rubbish and will leak
- As above but no leather as LR decided rubber was better - marginally better but still rubbish
- Upgrade kit STC4403. Good as it adds the mudshield but the seal is not that great.
- Upgrade kit STC4457. Not sure how this differs from the above.
Now you would think this is simple, just get STC4403 or STC4457  and change it all. But there's yet another seal 
AAU3381. Now this is a much improved seal and will actually last, you need to couple this with a flange that incorporates a mud shield. It will not fit the earlier flange as it will chew it out.
So in summary, always use AAU3381 and change the flange to one that incorporates a mud shield. As for torque and counting turns, just do what Justin said above, it worked for me.
Bookmarks