I too have the BD/Alive remap.Initially i had it done to eliminate the flat spot I had from 1st to 2nd,but am very happy with the improved drivability and power increases.I can't compare it to the BAS unit as Bruce never actually quoted power figures,and I never asked.I suppose the advantage of BAS is that you are able to remove/install the remap as it suits you,although I haven't had an issue returning the vehicle for warranty claims.I've recently had the EGR blocked off,both physically and electronically and that did cost a small amount to get the programme from Alive,only because the programme hadn't been developed at the time I had it done initially.Bruce has assured me that if I went ahead with the IC at a later date the upgrade for the ECU will be free.I'm tossing it around whether to go with the larger IC,as it's plenty powerful enough as it is,or is that even possible,I dunno.Maybe I'll change axles and flanges as well

Looking at the cost I think they are comparable.With BAS you get a new ECU,Alive uses your ECU.Personally,I'm not too interested in playing around with the ECU myself,and if anything were to go wrong,I know Bruce is more than happy to help.
Bookmarks