I vote Safari.
https://www.aulro.com/afvb/images/im...016/05/208.jpg
The Mantec has to be sealed to the guard, the inner guard piece sealed to the guard and to itself (it's two pieces), then to the intake pipe. Really not in the same league for preventing water ingress as the Safari, which is one piece through the guard straight to the intake pipe.
This mess, versus this.

