Thread: Space Case VS Roof Rack bag

Both are really for different uses , a bag i used for items like tent and bedding etc , hard case for tools, spares and cooking items.

Sent from my GT-I9300 using AULRO mobile app

I haven't used a space case but I have used a rack bag. I would think that in actual use there would be no contest, the convenience and lockability of a case would win hands-down, then there's the getting yourself and all your clean stuff covered in dust every time you open the bag, the fact that it has to be full to hold it's shape, the fact that the zips let dust and rain in...
A space-case is probably much more expensive plus has to be stored full-size between uses as opposed to a bag folding up small. Only two factors I can think of in favour of the bag.

We used a rhino roof top bag and it was excellent, fully weather and dust proof, however, doing it again would probably go the space case. Outside of the bag gets covered in crud like POD said and also we found the bag rubbed against the rack, not sure how long it would last if on an extended trip.

It sounds like you like the space case you have.
If you have one already why is it not usable?
If I had one already I'd be reluctant to spend money for a one trip use.

I've got a roof top bag that has served us well in the past.
Keeping it a shape to shed water and not pool is an art, both loaded and at camp.
I never had water ingress but did wrap things in rubish bags just incase.

We had a bag last year, was great for keeping dust out. Also kept water out whilst driving but was useless when stopped in rain, no matter how we arranged it water would seep through. Had to put everything into plastic boxes with lids to keep them dry in the bag. It was a top end canvas bag, very disappointing.

If the space case is fully waterproof and height is not a concern i would go the cases if we did a big trip again.

Hi Guys

thanks for the responses, i am glad they have not all been don't put anything up there, i am worried about all the weight on the rack