PDA

View Full Version : 3.54:1 Range Rover diffs into S2A?



Rocket88
9th January 2020, 07:26 AM
Hi All,

I know there is a thread (or a few!) about this, but I can't find the answer I'm looking for. I understand why the diff ratio change is desirable, and have picked up on the possibility of mixing/matching gearboxes/TCs to get the best combinations of gearbox & TC ratios for road driving and low speed bush work.

If I wanted to put 3.54:1 diffs in my S2A 88", would I just change the diff centres or do the early Range Rover diffs just "bolt in"? If they bolt in with few mods, it would provide a better braking solution as well I guess.

Any / all responses appreciated. This is a bit of navel contemplation at present as I try to work out my best options with "Jonesy" my 71 SWB diesel.

Thanks,

joe

goingbush
9th January 2020, 07:52 AM
if you need to ask then I suggest you don't even contemplate a RRC / D1 Axle swap into a Series .
You need to cut away / grind off all the brackets from RRC housings , manufacture / weld on appropriate spring perches. You need to allow sufficient room on the front so that the track rod does not rub on the leaf springs, which means higher front spring perches ( lowers the vehicle) . Must maintain RRC pinion upward angle to keep caster angle correct , then you need to cut a big hole in bottom of right engine mount so prop shaft does not hit it. need to convert to power boosted dual circuit brakes . nope not a bolt in conversion.


10 spline 3.54 RRC diff centres are a bolt in swap into the Series housings. .

Rocket88
9th January 2020, 08:33 AM
if you need to ask then I suggest you don't even contemplate a RRC / D1 Axle swap into a Series .
You need to cut away / grind off all the brackets from RRC housings , manufacture / weld on appropriate spring perches. You need to allow sufficient room on the front so that the track rod does not rub on the leaf springs, which means higher front spring perches ( lowers the vehicle) . Must maintain RRC pinion upward angle to keep caster angle correct , then you need to cut a big hole in bottom of right engine mount so prop shaft does not hit it. need to convert to power boosted dual circuit brakes . nope not a bolt in conversion.


10 spline 3.54 RRC diff centres are a bolt in swap into the Series housings. .

Thanks for the detailed information. I did need to ask, as I've not done this before. As to contemplating the job, or not, I am capable of many things, but time poor, so the diff centre swap will be the path I go down.

pop058
9th January 2020, 11:15 AM
The stage 1 diffs are leaf sprung and 3.54, so that could be a straight swap. The down side is that there are not many around " spare " at a reasonable price. Would give you the large front brakes as well.

PhilipA
9th January 2020, 11:18 AM
Just be careful to get diffs with the same filler arrangement as the s2.

Some RRC diffs have a filler on the nose and some no filler plug as it is on the rear.
Regards PhilipA

russellrovers
9th January 2020, 11:27 AM
The stage 1 diffs are leaf sprung and 3.54, so that could be a straight swap. The down side is that there are not many around " spare " at a reasonable price. Would give you the large front brakes as well.hi pop i have stage one diffs here need to take the whole stage one and use the parts jiim

pop058
9th January 2020, 11:56 AM
hi pop i have stage one diffs here need to take the whole stage one and use the parts jiim

PM me a figure please Jim.

JDNSW
9th January 2020, 12:05 PM
The stage 1 diffs are leaf sprung and 3.54, so that could be a straight swap. The down side is that there are not many around " spare " at a reasonable price. Would give you the large front brakes as well.

The problem with this solution is that in an 88 the rear diff is a Salisbury one, which would have to be installed as a complete axle assembly. Not only are the spring mounts in a different place from those on the 88, but the diff nose is much longer, resulting in a very short non-standard rear prop shaft and potentially universal angle problems.

goingbush
9th January 2020, 12:17 PM
Just be careful to get diffs with the same filler arrangement as the s2.

Some RRC diffs have a filler on the nose and some no filler plug as it is on the rear.
Regards PhilipA

Ahh yes, I had to add a Fill port on the Metric Disco diff housing I installed in the back of my Lightweight.

http://goingbush.com/AULRO/diff1.jpg

http://goingbush.com/AULRO/diff2.jpg

http://goingbush.com/AULRO/diff3.jpg

russellrovers
9th January 2020, 06:30 PM
PM me a figure please Jim. 3 .500 stopped because gearbx problem jim

Rocket88
9th January 2020, 07:41 PM
The problem with this solution is that in an 88 the rear diff is a Salisbury one, which would have to be installed as a complete axle assembly. Not only are the spring mounts in a different place from those on the 88, but the diff nose is much longer, resulting in a very short non-standard rear prop shaft and potentially universal angle problems.

Hi JDNSW, I assume you mean the "problem with this solution is that in a 109...."

If you've got a few minutes, I'm keen to chat to you about chassis (what is the plural?)

Thanks,

joe

JDNSW
10th January 2020, 06:07 AM
Hi JDNSW, I assume you mean the "problem with this solution is that in a 109...."

If you've got a few minutes, I'm keen to chat to you about chassis (what is the plural?)

Thanks,

joe

Maybe I could have worded that better.

The original question mentioned an 88, the Stage 1 was only made as a 109, so all Stage 1 diffs are from a 109.

The two chasses differ as follows:-

The 88 and 109 refer to the wheelbase in inches. In other words, the 88 is short wheelbase and the 109 is the long wheelbase. These wheelbases replaced 86 and 107 during Series 1 production when the engine bay was lengthened in 1956 for the diesel, and wheelbases were unchanged until the end of Series production.

The 109 chassis is deeper than the 88 as well as longer, but the key difference when considering axles is that the 88 has the rear springs under the chassis rails where the 109 has them further out, alongside the chassis rails.

Hope this helps.

Rocket88
10th January 2020, 11:26 AM
Thanks JDNSW, very helpful in raising my understanding of the differences between swb and lwb chassis, etc.

gromit
14th January 2020, 06:01 AM
Changing diff centres also raises the offroad gearing, a better option might be a high ratio transfer box conversion.

I was lucky as a vehicle I purchased came with one fitted.
Ashcroft in the UK supply the parts but you need someone to do the machining to complete the modification.

They only list the complete conversion here (and you have to send them your transfer case) but I'm sure they will also supply just the parts.
I also notice that it's not available till mid year.
Ashcroft Transmissions (https://www.ashcroft-transmissions.co.uk/the-series-vehicle/high-ratio-transfer-case-kit.html)

There are some pictures in this thread (a lot are missing thanks to Photobucket).
Isuzu C240 powered Series 3 (https://www.aulro.com/afvb/other-powered-series-land-rovers/151959-isuzu-c240-powered-series-3-a.html)

Mine has a N/A Isuzu 2.4 fitted. Pulls away OK and will keep up with the traffic on the freeway (just a bit slower getting up to top speed !).
Only downside is you really need to drop into 3rd below 60kph.


Colin

mick88
14th January 2020, 06:26 AM
Hi All,

I know there is a thread (or a few!) about this, but I can't find the answer I'm looking for. I understand why the diff ratio change is desirable, and have picked up on the possibility of mixing/matching gearboxes/TCs to get the best combinations of gearbox & TC ratios for road driving and low speed bush work.

If I wanted to put 3.54:1 diffs in my S2A 88", would I just change the diff centres or do the early Range Rover diffs just "bolt in"? If they bolt in with few mods, it would provide a better braking solution as well I guess.

Any / all responses appreciated. This is a bit of navel contemplation at present as I try to work out my best options with "Jonesy" my 71 SWB diesel.

Thanks,

joe

Joel,
an overdrive might be the best option for your vehicle as i assume when you say it's a diesel you mean a Land Rover 2.25 diesel engine.
At least with an overdrive you can disengage it and go back to standard gearing if your towing or in hilly country.
The high speed transfer case or higher ratio diff options won't allow you the flexibility of an overdrive.
I have 3.54 diffs in my S3 88 and i prefer them as they slow the complete drive train down by, so less noise, less wear, and far less oil getting thrown out ;) however i have an engine upgrade.

Cheers, Mick.

JDNSW
14th January 2020, 05:18 PM
For what it is worth, my view is that the standard gearing is quite suitable for the 2.25 engines, either petrol or diesel, especially when fitted with 7.50 tyres. There may be an argument for higher gearing if using smaller diameter tyres on an 88. (I have an overdrive on my 109 petrol, and very rarely use it)

These engines are quite happy at high rpm, and provided they are properly maintained, it will not hurt them. Above 60kph, in my experience, most noise in a Series Landrover with the holes in the firewall and floor properly blocked is road and wind noise.

gromit
15th January 2020, 05:53 AM
From memory the power output of the Isuzu C240 I have in my Series III was close to that of the Land Rover diesel.
I was 'warned' that the gearing would be way too high with the high ratio transfer box but this isn't the case.

If you can afford/justify a new overdrive then that could be the way to go. Finding a good Fairey or Toro overdrive could be difficult and reconditioning is expensive if parts are badly worn.

Maybe get it back on the road and then make a decision.


Colin

Rocket88
15th January 2020, 05:58 AM
From memory the power output of the Isuzu C240 I have in my Series III was close to that of the Land Rover diesel.
I was 'warned' that the gearing would be way too high with the high ratio transfer box but this isn't the case.

If you can afford/justify a new overdrive then that could be the way to go. Finding a good Fairey or Toro overdrive could be difficult and reconditioning is expensive if parts are badly worn.

Maybe get it back on the road and then make a decision.


Colin

Good advice, thanks Colin.

Tins
15th January 2020, 12:27 PM
If you can afford/justify a new overdrive then that could be the way to go. Finding a good Fairey or Toro overdrive could be difficult and reconditioning is expensive if parts are badly worn.




Colin

Colin, is the Canadian Roamerdrive an option. I know nothing about their reliability etc. They seem to be available in Sydney.

gromit
16th January 2020, 05:33 AM
Colin, is the Canadian Roamerdrive an option. I know nothing about their reliability etc. They seem to be available in Sydney.

That would be the overdrive of choice (funds permitting !).

Colin

ian4002000
16th January 2020, 06:55 PM
I took a pair of high speed diffs out of a series 3 shorty. The low speed are much better for general runnng around and made the vehicle a nicer car.
But this Landy does not go far and no freeway work.

Regards
Ian
bittern

Rocket88
16th January 2020, 07:42 PM
Do you still have the high speed diffs?

akelly
5th February 2020, 04:22 PM
I went down this track with my 2A shorty when the overdrive carked it. Put the 3.54 early rangie diff centres in (with the filler plug in the nose) and it became a total PITA to drive around down. 1st gear hillstarts were a clutch-destroying shambles, especially because mine is 186 powered. I ended up putting the original diff centres back in and fixing the overdrive - a much better combination for a series landy I think. I've seen posts where people match the gearbox and t-case ratios to better suit the 3.54 diffs, but in my opinion that's a lot of work when you can buy a good strong overdrive these days.