Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 12

Thread: Dual Fuel Flapper V8 will not run properly on petrol

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Nov 2020
    Location
    Wonthaggi VIC
    Posts
    10
    Total Downloaded
    0

    Dual Fuel Flapper V8 will not run properly on petrol

    Hi All, I'm looking for some moral support or direction to help me get my V8 going properly, I've been reading, reading, reading on this forum and others looking for ideas but I'm at the point where I need a fresh pair of eyes to help me.

    I have recently gone through the process of rebuilding my 3.5 from the bottom up to try to resolve a few problems that had been developing with age and mileage. The car had done approx. 380,000 kms before the rebuild.

    The engine has spent a fair bit of time at the shop and has included:
    • New crank
    • New bearings
    • New 9.75:1 compression pistons 20 thou oversize (original 8.13)
    • New rings
    • Revert to tin head gaskets (composite found when pulling apart)
    • New 3.5 camshaft
    • New valves
    • New lifters and rocker arms
    • Heads, block and inlet manifold skimmed


    Aside from shop work I have also:
    • Had the injectors refurbished
    • Replaced fuel and air filters
    • Replaced fuel pressure regulator
    • Completed Bee Utey's ignition coil modification
    • Checked TPS voltage (good)
    • Checked CTS resistance (bad)
    • Re-soldered every single pad on the ECU
    • Re-soldered the resistor block (was bad, now good)
    • Replaced the spark plugs and leads
    • Disconnected the 9th injector


    Before the rebuild the car had been developing more and more symptoms of being worn out, most notably worsening fuel economy and power, running hot, and becoming increasingly difficult to start at any temperature on either fuel. One morning of a camping trip it took me 15 minutes to get started, which finally triggered the rebuild.

    I now have the car running fairly sweetly on LPG, there is room for improvement but it idles evenly, revs smoothly, has seemingly as much power as it ever did and gets reasonable fuel economy for now at about 22L/100km.

    But I cannot get it to run right on petrol. It starts fairly quickly but runs very rough, and very rich blowing lots of smoke, will not idle, will rev but with a lot of hesitation and stumbling, and is way down on power versus the LPG. I've had to play around a bit with the timing to get it to drive without pinking which has ended up pretty close to 0 BTDC. Notably the LPG is quite timing agnostic and will run much more advance, but this timing seems to feel best for power and evenness on LPG, and runs at all for petrol. I know timing should be more advanced but I'm thinking that this is related to the increase in compression.

    Running the engine up to temperature on LPG this morning shows I have a bad CTS, which sat at 220 ohms from cold to hot, but my understanding is that it should be at about 300 ohms at running temperature anyway, so the failure mode should have it running ok when up to temp? I have also tried bypassing the CTS entirely and sitting a 300 ohm resistor in the plug but it seems to make no difference.

    Given the reasonable LPG experience I feel that I've eliminated ignition or cam timing, vacuum leaks or other mechanical items from being the problem which is leaving the fuel injection.

    Is there a chance I've inadvertently increased the compression so much that I'll never get it to run on petrol? I'm using 98 octane at the moment, as said seems to be running rich regardless but it's a bit scary that I can move the ignition timing around where it goes straight from being so retarded that it barely runs at all to pinking under any load with no sweet spot in between.

    The plan is to one day get rid of this fuel injection and megasquirt it, but right now I need some return on the money I've spent already!

    Appreciate any thoughts on what to try next. If anybody knows where I might find the flapper testing procedure, that's one I haven't done yet. The engine dies immediately if you unplug it whilst it's running, so it must be doing something!

  2. #2
    350RRC's Avatar
    350RRC is offline ForumSage Silver Subscriber
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Location
    Bellarine Peninsula, Brackistan
    Posts
    5,501
    Total Downloaded
    0
    Hi,

    This suggestion may not solve your problem but it only takes 5 min to see.

    Get under the car in front of the rear diff and see where the return fuel line enters the fuel tank (about halfway up), so you know what this looks like, etc.

    Find the fuel return line in the engine bay and blow air down it, ideally with the tank somewhat full.

    You should be able to hear bubbles being blown in the tank.

    If it seems blocked it will be most likely rust in the steel return line spigot, which can be cleared by disconnected the hose at the tank and poking wire through the spigot.

    I'm not saying that's your prob, but that is what was wrong with a carb 350 correctly jetted that ran rich for no apparent reason.

    DL

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Nov 2020
    Location
    Wonthaggi VIC
    Posts
    10
    Total Downloaded
    0
    Hi 350RRC,

    I've just run out and given this a go.

    So you're saying when I blow into the return hose, the result shouldn't be almost complete resistance whilst I put as much force on as I can, and then having the back pressure forcibly shoot the fuel back out of the hose and into my eye when I pull my mouth away?

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Nov 2020
    Location
    Wonthaggi VIC
    Posts
    10
    Total Downloaded
    0
    Further, this hard fuel line I've found where I got a big stick lodged the last time I drove the car before the rebuild shouldn't be pinched flat?

    I think you're on to something with the return line...

    IMG_20230704_193602350.jpg

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Jan 1970
    Location
    Two Rocks WA
    Posts
    1,361
    Total Downloaded
    0
    Hi do you know how many times the head and block have been decked?
    my previous Rangie 3.5 modded to 3.9 with holden 60 though pistons pinged like a dog on petrol until I fitted 30 thou composite head gaskets, I was then able to advance timing to 12 degrees btc and it ran good on lpg and petrol..I had no idea how many times it had been done before.
    it also my help to know how many cc your head combustion chamber is on your heads compared to a known stock head…PLR are you able to help?😃
    Range Rovers Have Charactors inside them
    LROCWA Ex member 23 years
    1971 Series 2A
    2004 Discovery2a V8 Auto
    2003 Discovery2a TD5 Manual
    1982 4door man (sadly now gone)
    1989 Vogue auto
    2011 TDV8 Vogue
    What would life be without a Rangie?



  6. #6
    Join Date
    Jun 2008
    Location
    Drouin East, Vic
    Posts
    2,780
    Total Downloaded
    0
    Have you checked the flap in the AFM? One LPG backfire, even with a blow-off system in place, will slam the thing shut under explosive force such that the pivot /hinge will be deformed and the flap will not move properly. If it is stuck partly open, the AFM will signal high airflow even at idle, the fuel will be metered accordingly and result in very rich mixture as you describe. I went through several of those AFMs before I saw the light- brings back bad memories!

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Nov 2020
    Location
    Wonthaggi VIC
    Posts
    10
    Total Downloaded
    0
    Hi All, I've been working furiously on this both figuratively and literally all weekend.

    Sadly replacing the crushed section of hard line made basically no difference to the running, but it was a good find to repair anyway.

    Some updates:

    Quote Originally Posted by Bradtot View Post
    Hi do you know how many times the head and block have been decked?
    my previous Rangie 3.5 modded to 3.9 with holden 60 though pistons pinged like a dog on petrol until I fitted 30 thou composite head gaskets, I was then able to advance timing to 12 degrees btc and it ran good on lpg and petrol..I had no idea how many times it had been done before.
    it also my help to know how many cc your head combustion chamber is on your heads compared to a known stock head…PLR are you able to help?😃
    Hi Bradtot, I have no idea what previous work has been done on the car, I picked it up with more than 350,000 on the clock. If I had to guess I would say the heads have been decked at least twice, once by me and the block decked probably once only by me. The engine had composite head gaskets on it which I don't think are correct for this year and there was other evidence of having had the heads off before. The engine number is still visible on the deck even after I had my work done so it can't have had too much taken off.

    I've always wondered how to get the combustion chamber CC, thinking about it I suppose it could be done with the head sitting upside down on a bench and use a measured liquid to see how much fits?? Too late now as I'm not taking them off again if I can get away with it.

    Quote Originally Posted by POD View Post
    Have you checked the flap in the AFM? One LPG backfire, even with a blow-off system in place, will slam the thing shut under explosive force such that the pivot /hinge will be deformed and the flap will not move properly. If it is stuck partly open, the AFM will signal high airflow even at idle, the fuel will be metered accordingly and result in very rich mixture as you describe. I went through several of those AFMs before I saw the light- brings back bad memories!
    I've been going through the magic GoMoG flapper guide I found at 87 RRC EFI Flapper 4cu trouble shooting wiring / ecu / AFM / regulator /, and also attached below for those who come later:

    LUCAS_L_FUEL_INJECTION.pdf

    The tests were made somewhat more difficult in a few spots due to what I would now describe as some absolute butchery of the engine management loom when the LPG was installed some 25 years ago.

    The AFM actually tested up perfectly, which was unexpected but nice to have at least some wins.

    What didn't test properly was the coolant sensor wiring, which despite me having a resistor bypassing the sensor was showing far too high resistance which was contributing to running rich. I managed to fix this and then moved on to...

    The TPS which wasn't set properly, I managed to get it reading 325mV at closed throttle but it only reads about 3.7V at WOT rather than 4.5V which it's supposed to, which I imagine will be pushing towards a lean mixture at high load. It had a nice even rate of change through the range but just doesn't get high enough.

    Also not testing properly were the injector circuits, of which cylinders 4 and 6 came up as open circuit! The connectors had disintegrated to the point where two weren't firing at all... which is why it was running so poorly. Both lean and rich, from a heap of sensors not working making the mixture rich but two cylinders not firing at all, or only firing on what was being scavenged.

    On fixing the injector circuits and starting the car finally some progress, running much more evenly but still very rich.

    Testing the injector circuits again now that they all had continuity, they were all reading about 40 Ohms resistance instead of 7-10, also reading about 11.4 volts instead of within 0.5 of battery which was 12.8 volts. This was doing my head in for ages as the resistance across the injectors was all testing perfectly at 2.4Ohm, and I had already fixed up the resistor pack so that each circuit was reading 6Ohm.. so WHY was this happening? I understand that too much resistance in the injector circuits also leads to running rich.

    It turns out that the LPG set up had the power supply to the injectors running off the same circuit as the fuel pump, so that they cut when switched to LPG, where they should have a clean power supply straight from the main relay. Fuel pump runs, voltage drops in the circuit. I don't understand why it was set up this way, with two relays taking a signal from the main circuit to open the fuel pump voltage to the injectors, rather than taking the signal from the fuel pump to just open the main voltage to the injectors per the original circuit. Simple enough to rectify, by changing the wiring on the relay terminals. When I close my eyes to sleep I'm going to be seeing the cut and shut soldered and taped wires I found in the loom as part of the LPG install.

    So, with that done and starting up it seemed... ok. Running evenly, stalling on idle, not hesitating so much when revved. Time for a drive to see how it's going on petrol.

    So far so good, not there yet but good enough to drive away from home, pull over a couple of times to advance the timing a bit as the pinking had stopped, gets up to 100km/h okay, not feeling powerful but so much better than it was...

    I try a full throttle pull at highway speed to see how it goes and it dies badly, foot off throttle and it's still dying badly... why? Suddenly terrible throttle response and losing speed. Drops down to 60km/h which is now top speed at full throttle on petrol. It worked for a good five minutes until I loaded it up and now it's worse than ever. Switch to LPG and go home.

    Back to the drawing board, go through the entire test procedure again. Everything tests perfectly, other than the TPS which hasn't changed from not getting high enough voltage at WOT. Runs terribly below 2000rpm held on throttle. Extremely hesitant to rev again. I'm running out of hair to pull out. Walk away for a few hours, come back and fiddle with the LPG relays again, maybe it was running the fuel pump voltage for a reason? No change. Walk away for a few more hours, start up to think about how it's responding again and it's running much better. Good enough for a drive? Out on the street get about 100m from the house and it drops revs and loses all power again. At least a short trip back. Sitting in the driveway holding the revs on throttle again and it suddenly kicks right up and becomes responsive! Then drops back down and loses power. Now an intermittent electrical fault!!! This is some sort of progress at least? Sitting in driveway and goes back and forth between running ok and changing to dying badly.

    Set up a trusty G-clamp on the butterfly to hold the revs and poking around at everything I've touched in the engine bay and I finally, finally discover... I can make it switch between running well and badly by jiggling the connection to the resistor block! Now that I've forced it to be in the right place... it drives on petrol!

    What a ****ing journey. Sorry for the exposition but I needed to share what I've done to get to where I am now.




    So... now it runs on petrol well enough that I would trust it on a journey, and know which wires to jiggle if it does fail. Huge win. But - it's still disappointingly down on power, vmax about 120km/h on petrol and worse than on LPG. It's timed up properly now that it's running on both fuels, at about 8BTDC.

    Somebody tell me it's the TPS not getting to 4.5 volts making it run lean under load, and the problem will go away if I sort that out? If so I could possibly even just ignore it until the big eventual megasquirt day, just knowing that I can at least switch to petrol to get me to the next LPG fill up if I have to.

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Jan 1970
    Location
    Avoca Beach
    Posts
    14,152
    Total Downloaded
    0
    Somebody tell me it's the TPS not getting to 4.5 volts making it run lean under load, and the problem will go away if I sort that out? If so I could possibly even just ignore it until the big eventual megasquirt day, just knowing that I can at least switch to petrol to get me to the next LPG fill up if I have to.
    No I won't tell you that because it isn't true.
    The TPS is like a volume control , variable resistor which tells the ECU how much fuel to inject. It really acts like an accelerator pump in a carby by giving demand calculation before the flapper is open enough to give the air mass reading.
    However The effect will just be that you do not get WOT as the primary source of air mass calculation is the flapper and a temperature sensor.
    Funny I ran a 14CUX for a couple of months without the TPS connected as the wire had separated and the only reason I knew was that the override injection cut did not work at 1500RPM.
    Regards PhilipA
    PS AFAIK your flapper will have a
    supplementary injector run by a thermo time switch. If the Thermo time switch is faulty the supplementary injector will keep injecting.
    Funny I fitted a Federal injection to a 77 RRC and a Thor manifold to a 14CUX but have not done anything with the flapper which was between the Federal and 14CUX.

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    Western Australia
    Posts
    260
    Total Downloaded
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by btbtbtbt View Post
    Set up a trusty G-clamp on the butterfly to hold the revs and poking around at everything I've touched in the engine bay and I finally, finally discover... I can make it switch between running well and badly by jiggling the connection to the resistor block! Now that I've forced it to be in the right place... it drives on petrol!

    What a ****ing journey. Sorry for the exposition but I needed to share what I've done to get to where I am now.




    So... now it runs on petrol well enough that I would trust it on a journey, and know which wires to jiggle if it does fail. Huge win. But - it's still disappointingly down on power, vmax about 120km/h on petrol and worse than on LPG. It's timed up properly now that it's running on both fuels, at about 8BTDC.

    Somebody tell me it's the TPS not getting to 4.5 volts making it run lean under load, and the problem will go away if I sort that out? If so I could possibly even just ignore it until the big eventual megasquirt day, just knowing that I can at least switch to petrol to get me to the next LPG fill up if I have to.
    Over the years, I have recommended to so many people that have had odd running and starting issues with the flapper EFI in RRCs (since I had to diagnose and quite literally do my own roadside repair which exposed this very issue) is that the first place to start is the wiring and plug on the resistor pack, including moving it around while the engine is running as there is usually some defect to be found in either the terminals of the connector or the pins on the resistor pack. This is due to how the resistor pack is positioned from factory and how the wiring harness is routed to the resistor pack in typical British ingenuity fashion. And from my experience, both the flapper and hotwire systems are extremely sensitive to the parameters/readings of the TPS, which is unfortunate because there is no new OE ones, real genuine NOS ones are exceptionally rare and eye-wateringly expensive, all of the aftermarket ones that I have encountered have been defective and the only conversion kit that I can remember seeing is offered by Tornado UK at considerable cost, there may have also been another that converted to a Ford TPS.


    Anyway, glad to know that you got it running 'well enough' again. I would definitely be resolving the TPS issue before proceeding and if it is the real Lucas original TPS, doing whatever you can to save it. Alternatively, you can also use a TPS from a hotwire system but you will probably need to modify the plastic ears of where the TPS mounts so that it is adjustable, as the original flapper TPSs were. Reason being is that the hotwire EFI TPS has no adjustment in position/rotation as the EFI could "self-learn" throttle use and compensate the TPS within reason.

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Nov 2020
    Location
    Wonthaggi VIC
    Posts
    10
    Total Downloaded
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by PhilipA View Post
    No I won't tell you that because it isn't true.
    Ah well, a man can dream of a simple swap and fix!

    Quote Originally Posted by Chivalry View Post
    Anyway, glad to know that you got it running 'well enough' again. I would definitely be resolving the TPS issue before proceeding and if it is the real Lucas original TPS, doing whatever you can to save it. Alternatively, you can also use a TPS from a hotwire system but you will probably need to modify the plastic ears of where the TPS mounts so that it is adjustable, as the original flapper TPSs were. Reason being is that the hotwire EFI TPS has no adjustment in position/rotation as the EFI could "self-learn" throttle use and compensate the TPS within reason.
    I have a hotwire TPS handy but I'm not looking to modify it just yet as I'll need it when I turf this whole fuel injection... budgetary constraints are keeping me from getting to that for a little while yet.

    So I've been on a couple of big drives now which has been mostly joyous on LPG, aside from a couple of experiences of completely random hard starting as in minutes of cranking, which only happens away from home and screams out wet plugs despite having shut down at full hot and not used petrol at all for the whole trip. Symptoms being firing once but failing to start and then firing one cylinder only on cranking on any fuel including none selected, and mercifully eventually starting full throttle when the planets have moved around a bit.

    The car sings along at 110km/h pretty comfortably, which is strange because absolute top speed as tested on my private runway seems to be around 125km/h which is surely way too low given I can run up a moderate hill at 110 in third gear.

    Petrol as a backup fuel has been working well enough where I have been able to hold an unhappy 100km/h unless any sort of incline rears its head. Until recently that is, where hauling flat out up a hill something electrical has given way yet again and now I'm way down on power. AFM, TPS, CTS, resistor pack all testing fine. Maybe the whole ECU has let go this time? Running "smoothly" under throttle on petrol after starting on gas, won't idle, will rev up extremely hesitantly and I could probably barely putt around the block if I had to but annoyingly not really good enough to go anywhere far away from an LPG bowser right now.

    I've finally picked up a fuel pressure gauge as well, regulator is regulating nicely at 38 psi, but pressure drops what seems quickly, down to 22 psi after 60 seconds and down to 12 psi after 20 minutes. Is that way too fast? Are my injectors leaking and causing my hard starts?

    If I can jiggle the next thing into getting back to where I was on petrol I'll update again.

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Tags for this Thread

Bookmarks

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Search AULRO.com ONLY!
Search All the Web!