
Originally Posted by
disco man
Story by defence analysis Ross Eastgate.
Every individual carries for a lifetime the consequences of personal actions. Perhaps none so more than those who have experienced military combat first hand,when instant decisions do not always end with intended consequences. At 0735hrs on Monday,October 23,1967, 2 Platoon A Coy 2RAR initiated an ambush in AO Petre,Phuoc Tuy Province in Vietnam when 14 individuals walked into the killing zone. The ambush was situated 2000m into a restricted area and the individuals were observed wearing packs and carrying what were later indentified as sticks. There were no Australian casualties but four Vietnamese were killed,six wounded plus three unhurt who were reported to be 'hysterical'. The following day another wounded Vietnamese was located and medically evacuated. The incident is clearly recorded in the war diaries of both 2RAR and HQ 1ATF,and was reported to both the Deputy Chief of the General Staff and Minister for the Army in November 1967.
Despite this clear evidence last week journalist Matthew Benns claimed there was "an official cover-up that wiped any record of the incident from the official history," "the published official histories sanitised(the incident)";which(was removed)from the official history";and "had been air-brushed from the official history". Further he claimed the company commander the late Peter White MC suggested placing weapons on the bodies would have somehow added credibility to the ambush outcome. Peter White died in 2005 and cannot defend himself but this slur on the reputation of an honourable man cannot go unchallenged. Benns could have,but obviously did not,check the reports of the ambush which are readily accessible on the Australian War Memorial website. There are no deletions,removals or cover-ups in the digitised copies of the original reports. The incident has been accurately reported in subsequent histories.
Even if the already overloaded 2RAR infantrymen had the capacity to carry 'spare' weapons to throw down beside the bodies,there was absolutely no benefit in doing so because the incident was not subject to coronial inquiry in Vietnam or Australia. In the same week Benns'article was published ,at a Brisbane coronial inquiry a senior lawyer experienced in arguing both sides of criminal matters threw down an equally damaging allegation that an Australian army officer had somehow "irresponsibly" failed to perform his duties when three soldiers were murdered by a rouge Afghani colleague. "There are three families grieving here because you didn't do your job!" thundered Peter Bodor QC until cautioned by deputy Queensland coroner John Lock. Emotional damage to the witness was irreparably done,because just like the Benns'article,once uttered they cannot be undone. Nor can the 2RAR diggers undo the events on that fateful 1967 morning despite then Major White's commendations of their actions once the situation had been clarified.
The current Queensland coronial inquiry will not alter past events in Afghanistan but merely bring more anguish to the survivors. Guilt is a difficult companion; however truth even when unpalatable remains a loyal friend.
Called, looking for a scape goat. Truth is indeed a loyal friend. That inquiry, and the performance by Bodor, par for the course, unfortunately, Bob
I’m pretty sure the dinosaurs died out when they stopped gathering food and started having meetings to discuss gathering food
A bookshop is one of the only pieces of evidence we have that people are still thinking
Bookmarks