Thread: 20000 IGNORANTS calling for ban 4WDs

Originally Posted by CraigE

Done, every member should be sending this hypocrit a message, flood her website with opposition otherwise the minorities will have their say.

FFS people SHE IS NOT IN FAVOUR OF THE PETITION

Emails with diatribe like that give ammo to the 4WD haters, and make us look like tools.
I think the petition is pathetic, and it gives me the irrits, but it's the media and the "petitioner" people should be blasting.

Did you read any of this thread?
She is NOT in favour of the petition, or any part of it.
She is the opposition transport minister and as such was obliged to table the petition.

From the Sunshine Coast Daily:
Ms Simpson, the opposition's transport spokeswoman, said she did not support the ban but the principal petitioner who lives at Currumbin on the Gold Coast had right to see the document tabled.

"I do not support bans upon four-wheel-drives nor do I endorse the proposal of my constituent," Ms Simpson said.

“When I received it, I told the petitioner I did not agree with his views but I believed he had a right to have it tabled.

“Once misreported, these things morph into myths.

"This was not my petition, nor did I write or endorse it.

"I tabled it through the Clerk of Parliament as MPs routinely do for petitions, regardless of whether they concur with the sentiments.

“It is definitely not LNP policy to ban four wheel drives in school zones or shopping centres or to hike their registration fees."

However, Ms Simpson said she did agree with a petition tabled earlier this year protesting against the Bligh government's vehicle registration hike.

Finally, someone said it. All you guys sending bulk emails to her are just making all of us look like *****.

Originally Posted by FenianEel

FFS people SHE IS NOT IN FAVOUR OF THE PETITION

Emails with diatribe like that give ammo to the 4WD haters, and make us look like tools.
I think the petition is pathetic, and it gives me the irrits, but it's the media and the "petitioner" people should be blasting.

Did you read any of this thread?
She is NOT in favour of the petition, or any part of it.
She is the opposition transport minister and as such was obliged to table the petition.

From the Sunshine Coast Daily:
Ms Simpson, the opposition's transport spokeswoman, said she did not support the ban but the principal petitioner who lives at Currumbin on the Gold Coast had right to see the document tabled.

"I do not support bans upon four-wheel-drives nor do I endorse the proposal of my constituent," Ms Simpson said.

“When I received it, I told the petitioner I did not agree with his views but I believed he had a right to have it tabled.

“Once misreported, these things morph into myths.

"This was not my petition, nor did I write or endorse it.

"I tabled it through the Clerk of Parliament as MPs routinely do for petitions, regardless of whether they concur with the sentiments.

“It is definitely not LNP policy to ban four wheel drives in school zones or shopping centres or to hike their registration fees."

However, Ms Simpson said she did agree with a petition tabled earlier this year protesting against the Bligh government's vehicle registration hike.

"Dear Member,
Could you please pay attention to the simple fact that your right to express a view is a result of a certain number of Australian citizens CHOOSING you as their ELECTED member. You are there to represent the views of the MAJORITY of your constituents NOT just your own personal views.
As a memeber of the responsible 4wd owning community, I object to you using your position to promote a view which is way out of line with such a large proportion of the community who choose drive 4wd vehicles.
Your position is at best ill informed, at worst, a blatant misuse of your elected and priveledged position."

There's my little protest in her inbox

Originally Posted by wardy1

"Dear Member,
Could you please pay attention ....(try it yourself mate)

You are there to represent the views of the MAJORITY of your constituents NOT just your own personal views.

Can you read Wardy1?
That's exactly what She did.

Originally Posted by FenianEel

Can you read Wardy1?
That's exactly what She did.

I understood very well her view and my spanglish it is not the best

I think that the problem is to many people drink to much coffee and type before engage the brain

Ok....it is my fault...I started the thread

Originally Posted by Lotz-A-Landies

But be aware you may end up with higher service costs when they have to pay Australians at Australian wage rates and benefits and have to cope with Australian work-ethics and waiting queues.

BTW: Is your username meant to be ironic?

Not always true.
We are with west net for our phone and internet. Our bills are significantly cheaper and they only have call centers in Australia.
Last time telstra tried to win us back I told them not till they can match e price and service level. Never heard from them since

Originally Posted by FenianEel

FFS people SHE IS NOT IN FAVOUR OF THE PETITION

Emails with diatribe like that give ammo to the 4WD haters, and make us look like tools.
I think the petition is pathetic, and it gives me the irrits, but it's the media and the "petitioner" people should be blasting.

Did you read any of this thread?
She is NOT in favour of the petition, or any part of it.
She is the opposition transport minister and as such was obliged to table the petition.

From the Sunshine Coast Daily:
Ms Simpson, the opposition's transport spokeswoman, said she did not support the ban but the principal petitioner who lives at Currumbin on the Gold Coast had right to see the document tabled.

"I do not support bans upon four-wheel-drives nor do I endorse the proposal of my constituent," Ms Simpson said.

“When I received it, I told the petitioner I did not agree with his views but I believed he had a right to have it tabled.

“Once misreported, these things morph into myths.
Exactly why she should make it very, very clear she does not concur.

"This was not my petition, nor did I write or endorse it.

"I tabled it through the Clerk of Parliament as MPs routinely do for petitions, regardless of whether they concur with the sentiments.

“It is definitely not LNP policy to ban four wheel drives in school zones or shopping centres or to hike their registration fees."

However, Ms Simpson said she did agree with a petition tabled earlier this year protesting against the Bligh government's vehicle registration hike.

That is all welll and good but unless she makes it quite clear in the media and on her web site then it will be inferered that this is the consensus of the population. Unless she hears from the other side too, it could be infered that this is the consensus.
I stand by my remarks 100%, our politicians should be foccussing on sorting the major issues in this country rather than trivial issues like what cars people should be allowed to own. And on the flip sign I have not seen much evidence that she supports 4x4 ownership either.

Originally Posted by CraigE

Done, every member should be sending this hypocrit a message, flood her website with opposition otherwise the minorities will have their say.

I have had a reply from Fiona Simpson and it follows and I still believe we need to let our MP's know our opposition especially those in Fiona's electorate.

Dear Mr Elphick
Thank you for contacting me directly. At least then I have a chance to reply. Unfortunately this story has been wrongly reported and is fast morphing into a myth.
I do not support banning four wheel drives and never have.
I refer you to the following links on my website.
4-wheel drive petition correction - Fiona Simpson MP
Simpson rejects 4WD ban call - Fiona Simpson MP
Regards
Fiona Simpson

My reply to Fiona

Fiona,
Thankyou for taking the time to reply. I am pretty much straight forward and believe in confronting an issue straight up which is why I contacted you directly. Though I am not in your electorate, I do believe it is very important to show the other side of the issue as a 4x4 owner and someone who is probablly infact in the majority (for example every 2nd home where we live has a 4x4, probablly moreso). I do hope you are able to convey your personal thoughts successfully otherwise it does give a undue misrepresentation.
Thanks
Craig