Looking at the catalogue, the latest revision has been used on the D3 since MY08 from VIN (V)8A443195 and is the same used on all later vehicles (D3/D4/RRS). So, it seems that the issue will not be improved with most current part.
Printable View
Looking at the catalogue, the latest revision has been used on the D3 since MY08 from VIN (V)8A443195 and is the same used on all later vehicles (D3/D4/RRS). So, it seems that the issue will not be improved with most current part.
Just looking at the workshop manual. It says:
"CAUTION: The bolt securing the toe link to the wheel knuckle must not be used more than 5 times. Mark the bolt head with a suitable centre punch."
In other places its says to discard the bolt once it is removed and replace with a new one:
"3. Disconnect the toe link.
Remove and discard the bolt."
I think the first reference is incorrect and has not been updated to state that they can not be reused.
It seems that the bolt will fatigue from the torque applied when tightened numerous times. It is understandable that shops not in the know may reuse the bolt or even use rattle guns on them.
With this in mind I would be inclined to discard the bolt any time it is removed and using a new one in its place. Also, if there is to be any suspension work done (alignment, wheel bearing etc ) by anyone I'll be letting them know.
Graeme, you may want to get a new bolt to replace the one you removed for inspection.
I didn't get to remove the bolt. Judging by the uninterrupted crust of dirt around the heads and washers there is currently no looseness. I thought I found information that the bolt was updated to its current part# prior to the D4 introduction, which now appears to be confirmed. Hence no benefit in checking the bolt but I will get spares and may change them purely because of the vehicle's kms. However as only a small percentage of vehicles seem to have broken bolts, I suspect kms or usage is not a contributing factor.
I expect the advice to replace after removal is due to the bolt being pre-treated with locking compound that is only effective on the first use. I suspect the bolts are breaking because they are not properly tight and therefore are being bent/flexed back and forth until they fatigue enough to finally break at the point at which they are restrained. It would be real interesting to see a close-up of the remains of the broken-off bolt and of both end faces of the metal centre of the bush, looking for the stress signs on the bolt indicating how the bolt broke and any wear marks on the bush indicating whether or not there was movement. It would be easy to tell if the bolt has been fatigued by movement or whether it has sheared from a big hit. The bolt head might also tell a story but its not likely to be found.
Until the reason for the bolts breaking becomes properly identified, their breaking is a cause for concern.