I've used this for a jerry can cap that I had problems getting a seal on.
Nitrile Cork Sheet - 300mm x 214mm x 1.5mm A4 SIZE SEAL JOIN FREE POST | eBay
used for diesel and has been in service for at least 2 years without any problems. I think your rubber problem might be that they have given you natural rubber. Neoprene is OK to good and Nitrile is generally listed as Good to Excellent.
Cheers Glen


Reply With Quote

Bookmarks