Thread: The end of cruise ships, as we know them?

Originally Posted by 350RRC

Does that really mean just shut the stateroom door and open the the window (portholes are only good for the LHS)?

DL

If you have ever noticed small louvre panels in say, Office doors down low, well, that is where the air returns to the main system albeit it may pass through other open plan areas, say a General Office, to reach the Return Air Grille/Duct.

It doesn't matter if the door is closed the grille can still relieve the pressure in a room & if it was a sealed door then it would tend to pressurise & in turn restrict air flow to that room.

Sometimes with bad design a gap may be left beneath a door instead of a grille but that is very hit & miss & air needs to be recycled back to the main unit & that is where Ruby Princess & Mick's ship comes into it.

You finish up with all people's 'goozys' floating through the air.

Originally Posted by DiscoMick

It was interesting that when we left Tassie on the Spirit of Tasmania they assured us that the aircon for each section of the vessel drew its air from outside and not from other parts of the vessel. AFAIK there have been no cases of the virus on the Spirit. So apparently it can be done.

Just believe what they tell you Mate, She will be right

Originally Posted by 350RRC

Does that really mean just shut the stateroom door and open the the window (portholes are only good for the LHS)?

DL

Sorry missed that question somewhere.?? Opening the Port Hole buggers up the design conditions for that space & not just for that space, the whole system.

Most people wouldn't give a flying **** so long as they have air but getting the quantities right means maximum comfort.

Originally Posted by scarry

The current standard for inside and outside air in cruise ships requires they have 10 liters per second per passenger of outside air in a cabin, he said. The air inside a cabin that is returned, or carried, to other areas could be up to 90% of the total air in other spaces. In other words, that 90% could contain coronavirus if it came from an area where someone had the virus.

Thats not miles away from a land based system.
From memory,a classroom needs 5l/sec per person in the room.
But its a while since i have done a lot of AC design.

So there is a 99% chance the staff on the Spirit of Tassie were telling porkies.

They said “each section” - not each cabin

Originally Posted by 4bee

If you have ever noticed small louvre panels in say, Office doors down low, well, that is where the air returns to the main system albeit it may pass through other open plan areas, say a General Office, to reach the Return Air Grille/Duct.

It doesn't matter if the door is closed the grille can still relieve the pressure in a room & if it was a sealed door then it would tend to pressurise & in turn restrict air flow to that room.

Sometimes with bad design a gap may be left beneath a door instead of a grille but that is very hit & miss & air needs to be recycled back to the main unit & that is where Ruby Princess & Mick's ship comes into it.

You finish up with all people's 'goozys' floating through the air.

The bottom line is, if the air can't relieve,it won't be coming in.So you will end up with one hot and stuffy cabin.

These days i bet there is also some sort of Toilet exhaust system as well,which will take some of the conditioned supply air out.

So there is a 99% chance the staff on the Spirit of Tassie were telling porkies

Yep, more of that Fake Noos stuff.

Originally Posted by Tombie

They said “each section” - not each cabin

Section or whatever,it still won't be drawing all its air from outside.So it still comes from other sections or areas,or cabins,or wherever,,not full fresh air,which is what they implied.

Originally Posted by trout1105

Considering that these cruise ships are responsible for a large percentage of COV19 cases who in their right mind would ever board one of these plague ships now?

China is likely responsible for the whole Covid-19 thing. Who in their right mind would buy anything from Bunnings??

Sheesh. Yes, I would board a cruise ship if I was that way inclined ( I never have been, in case you ask ). Yes, I will get on an airplane. Yes, I will go to a shopping centre. Yes, I would go to my son's party.

Are you now going to live your life based on some pathetic beat up? This virus is real, sure. Have you actually looked at its mortality rate compared to the usual flu? I'll bet not. The rates are incomparable, the flu is far worse, and the flu kills kids, but you are scared of something that kills the elderly or weak? I'm approaching elderly, and I am certainly weak compared to my younger self, and am I scared? No, I am not, and neither should you be.

I can't believe the ignorance shown on this forum about this virus. It is a virus. They happen. People die due to viral infection. This happens every day. I'm sure you all know this. The thing that astounds me is that you don't grasp that this Covid is now here for ever. It is not something that has just popped up and will go away, it is now here for ever. Like every other virus. We won't beat it. We will adapt.

This media driven panic will be repeated ad infinitum unless we learn that it's not the virus that's the enemy, it's us.