Well after the last week, I wholeheartedly agree with this sentiment that the OEM tyres are not good for punctures after some wear. We have just finished a trip to the Bendleby Ranges in the Southern Flinders ranges and punctured three of the OEM Goodyear Wranglers:
- 1 on bitumen with a 3" nail (this mysteriously appeared after we stopped in Clare for lunch and I noticed a few young locals hanging around the car

). I only noticed it when I lost the back-end of the car going around a sweeping corner at 110km/h towing a trailer. Luckily I caught it in time, so this one is repairable
- 1 on dirt road. Unfortunately, this was my fault. I was still running high-load, bitumen tyre pressures (42 PSI on rear) after going from bitumen to high speed dirt roads. This one wasn't repairable because I must have run on it for a while before noticing it. In fact, I must have been quite some time, as I only noticed it when the suspension went into limp mode - I little scary until I worked out what the problem was!
- 1 through the sidewall on a slow rough, rocky creek bed. Again, not repairable.
Thank goodness I has invested in a tyre repair kit and good compressor. What a great piece of kit! I used this kit to temporarily repair two of the tyres while still on the car! This was enough to get us home to Adelaide safely.
The tyres had 11k on them and were roughly 30 - 40% worn by my estimate. By way of comparison, we did this same trip last year on new tyres and didn't have any problems. Maybe we just got lucky last time, but they certainly don't seem to perform as well once they have a few kms on them.
Needless to say, I am in the process of following others' leads and replacing them with something else. I am also leaning towards the Pirelli Scorpion ATRs, as we do 95% road and only 5% offroad.
Bookmarks