
Originally Posted by
MR LR
I'm not going to agree to disagree, because you're wrong.
As far as I'm concerned, anything that increases overhang (the distance from the tow point to the rear axle) on these vehicles is bad design.
Haha we never disagreed on that point - and it actually supports my argument that it's more important than wheelbase (the ratio is not 3/4!). What I questioned was your assertion that there's no real difference between overhangs of utes and D4s. Then you tried to bring wheel base into it, so I'll quote Robert Pepper July 2015
"If we look at the modern ute then we find they have very long overhangs, and their relatively long wheelbases don't entirely compensate. Utes that have the rear wheels close to the rear doors are great for turning circles, but hopeless for load carrying and towing. Most utes could be much better towers and load carriers if they had wheels about 200-300mm further back."
He also mentions that the 90, 110 and 130 all have different overhangs, incidentally.
Obviously departure angle changes with ride height which is why I quoted the angle at standard height (185mm) for the D4 which is /way/ less than most other 4WDs - and yet the departure angle /is still better than most mainstream wagons/. D4 = 26.7; Y62 Patrol = 25.9; LC200 Cruiser = 24; Prado = 25. Grand Cherokee 29.6, but then, by the time the D4 is at offroad height it's 31, so same same. Granted I don't know what role the actual towbar plays in those figures but they're all in the ball park. Wheelbase you say? Prado shorter. Even the LC200's wheelbase is 2850 compared to D4's 2885 mm (why is anyone buying a Land Cruiser??). Grand Cherokee is longer, interestingly, but hopefully you get my point.
Why you would suggest a ute is going to be as good or better at towing than a D4 I just don't know.
Now 2016 D4 HSE 'Leo' and Steve the Triumph Speed Twin
Then 2010 D4 3.0 HSE 'James'
Then 2010 RRS TDV8 'Roger' w traxide DBS, UHF, Cooper Zeons, Superchips remap
Then 2010 D4 TDV6 'Jumbo' w traxide DBS
First love 2002 D2 TD5 'Disco Stu'
Bookmarks