I assume that the axles are all Series 2/2a 88/109 and Series 3 early 88, and all have ten spline both ends.
Series 1 Landrovers very rarely broke axles, either 86/88 or 107/109, as these were semifloating and much more robust.
Same applied to Series 2, either 88 or 109.
However, by the time sixes were introduced, producing significantly more power, and as users found they could mostly get away with even more gross overloading than they managed with Series 1, broken axles became more common, added to this was decreasing quality control after the Leyland merger in 1967. So that by late 2a production broken axles were a known issue, leading to the optional Salisbury rear axle on late 2as. These became standard on Series 3 109s. (And late Series 3 88s got 24 spline outer ends to match the 109s, to allow commonality of drive flanges etc.)
As a result, by the 1980s, there were third parties producing replacement axles that were tougher than the late Rover ones, and although the main issue was steel quality and heat treatment, it is probable that at least some of these were thicker. I have only ever broken one axle in a Series Landrover, and that was in 1968. And I can't remember whether the replacement was genuine or third party, or whether it was the same diameter as the original.
I hope this may shed some light.


 
						
					 
					
					 
				
				
				
					 Reply With Quote
  Reply With Quote 
						
					 
						
					 
					
					 Originally Posted by JDNSW
 Originally Posted by JDNSW
					
 
				 
						
					 
						
					 
						
					 
				 
						
					 
			
Bookmarks