Thread: 16 p to 10 p engine swap

Originally Posted by johnp38

You can buy a used MSB from an auto and it will be ok in the manual too.

I hate to correct you but for accuracy i have to say that for an auto ECU to be OK on a manual beside the remap it needs an invasive intervention to build the clutch switch's input circuit to pin 35 of the black plug which is missing in the auto ECU and without that will be surge on gear change, not a good option IMO even if the engine runs with it.

Originally Posted by sierrafery

I hate to correct you but for accuracy i have to say that for an auto ECU to be OK on a manual beside the remap it needs an invasive intervention to build the clutch switch's input circuit to pin 35 of the black plug which is missing in the auto ECU and without that will be surge on gear change, not a good option IMO even if the engine runs with it.

If you're changing up or down gears in normal driving without cruise engaged you are backing off on accelerator anyway between changes so not really an issue.

Problem is when you are in cruise and push clutch pedal and engine accelerates to keep up speed.

Bit of awareness and the driver can work around the few times that function may be needed.

Originally Posted by sierrafery

I hate to correct you but for accuracy i have to say that for an auto ECU to be OK on a manual beside the remap it needs an invasive intervention to build the clutch switch's input circuit to pin 35 of the black plug which is missing in the auto ECU and without that will be surge on gear change, not a good option IMO even if the engine runs with it.

I ran a tuned auto ECU in my Defender for a while and do not recommend. Its been a while so my memory fails me a bit on exactly how the vehicle behaved, but I'd certainly never do it again unless to get out of a pickle.

Originally Posted by ross_coupland

Perhaps a little off topic, but can a 'cheap' MSB ecu (say from a wrecker) be adapted so that it can be programmable/able to be remapped?
I have a '99 D2 Td5 manual that I'd love to have a mild tune put in, but finding the correct NNN ecu is prohibitively difficult!

Join the club.

This is a good vid on what's involved in swapping the chip out. There's a few mobs around who'll do it and program it. Don't know if I'd trust (tune wise) the easily accessible UK ones though.

HOW TO CHIP LAND ROVER TD5 Defender and Discovery - YouTube

He's got another vid with a dual map MSB switchable via toggle switch. good stuff indeed

Originally Posted by johnp38

Yes but it has to be opened and the chip unsoldered and replaced with a socket soldered in its place.

But each time you want to change the programming ( 'tune' ) the chip has to be removed from the socket (so taking ecu out and lid off each time) and replaced with another one with new tune, or if it is a re flashable chip it can be updated in a programming unit with the new tune.

I have 2 MSB units with sockets and a programmer and re flashable chips and fart around with tunes to my hearts content ( hobbyist not tuning guy). I've got it down pat and disconnect battery, lift ecu out over tray without unplugging it, lid off, pull chip out and replace with next 'no idea what I am doing' tune and back together again and cross fingers it starts and drives !

You can buy a used MSB from an auto and it will be ok in the manual too.

On ebay you will find tunes already programmed into chips and you buy the chip with the socket that needs to be soldered in.

Land rover TD5 Discovery Defender MSB PERFORMANCE CHIP TUNE (self Install DIY) | eBay

Just wondering if it's possible to configure out the "lift off flare" by playing around with the tables without a clutch switch?

Originally Posted by Discosux

Just wondering if it's possible to configure out the "lift off flare" by playing around with the tables without a clutch switch?

It is, but not much is known about the maps that control it...

I've done a defender back here running a NNN500030, it's quite serviceable with it done, BUT if you have cruise control and use it...I wouldn't be trying that.

Cheers
James

Originally Posted by shack

BUT if you have cruise control and use it...I wouldn't be trying that.

Cheers
James

A programmable throttle controller should fix that. plus give 60 / 80 / 100 don't exceed setpoints and heaps of other stuff.

Stock CC is garbage anyway

Originally Posted by Discosux

A programmable throttle controller should fix that. plus give 60 / 80 / 100 don't exceed setpoints and heaps of other stuff.

Stock CC is garbage anyway

Mine are all ok...!

But not stock.