Originally Posted by
BradC
I am thinking about WOT as frankly that is all that matters. If you aren't at WOT then more throttle gives more power. You might suggest that EGR alters the slope throttle/power delivery curve, although I didn't feel a difference when I programmed mine out. If I have the same amount of power on tap, then they haven't reduced power output.
The idea is to use recirculated gas whenever full power isn't required to reduce chamber temperature which significantly reduces the production of oxides of nitrogen. Theoretically you can do that at any point of the power curve, but they program them up such that when you need more right foot they close up to allow more oxygen into the cylinder.
Even the old petrol EGR systems had a solenoid to ensure they are shut off at WOT.
Frankly, if the EGR wasn't such a huge point of crippling unreliability in these motors I'd have left it in place. Same with the DPF, but the issues far outweighed the "no black smoke and no smell", so out it went.