Thread: Video comparison: Defender 110 vs Jeep Rubicon (1/2 hr vid)

The biggest problem for the Rubicon, apart from the fact that it is a Jeep, is that you can't carry more than a cheese sandwich with thin slices of bread. It really is a rort. Andrew makes a good point about that. Towing the Jeep is a joke too. Cheers

Originally Posted by tact

Both in low reverse and low first in TDCi defenders: When the clutch pedal is almost fully up the position sensor on the clutch pedal signals and the ECU ramps idle speed up a few hundred rpm

Normal (for TDCi defenders in low range and first/reverse)

That (little) speed increase can give you a scare. But the crawling speed of the vehicle is still damn slow and controlled.

And yes... If you press the brake (only) to stop the vehicle when it's motoring in low range 1st/rev (on slope or level ground!) it's not going to stop easily!

Hey Tact, I've moved this post over to a new thread because this is important and has nothing to do with jeep comparo. (Mods, sorry you may want to move this again, or move our other related posts?) Cheers,

Originally Posted by Marty90

Rubicon has sway- bar disconnect I think,which would explain the good articulation.The video surprised me really.I thought Mr.St Pierre- White was going to bag the Defender.He keeps comparing the Defender to other brands,just to bag Defenders.Rubicon is top of the range.Doesn't the transfer case have some ridiculously low gearing in low range. Rock hopping's what they're built for.Apples and oranges.

Yep, the Rubicon has a 4.0:1 low range t/case giving 73:1 low/low, diff locks f/r, etc.
They are supplied with the right bits for hard off roading.
Nothing wrong with that.

The Jeep front end will pretty much always out flex a stock Landy radius arm front end, it's just the way they are designed.

Naturally enough this same video was talked about over in the Jeep forum I also pimp in...

Far more mature comments from the Defender owners here though.... good onya guys!

Regards
Daz

Originally Posted by ozscott

The biggest problem for the Rubicon, apart from the fact that it is a Jeep, is that you can't carry more than a cheese sandwich with thin slices of bread. It really is a rort. Andrew makes a good point about that. Towing the Jeep is a joke too. Cheers

and there I was saying how much more mature comments are over here than the JK Wrangler forum (ausjeepoffroad) that are talking about the same video..

Opinions vary......
AULRO = Defender biased.
ausjeepoffroad = JK Wrangler biased.

Perosnally as I have a passion for both models, I say it should have been..

Defender TDCi & JK Wrangler Vs Anything else you want to throw at them.

Regards
Daz

Mate I was having a bit of of fun but the cheese sandwich comment stands.

Cheers

Low first is so low in my Defender I've had to accelerate downhill at times. It's great for idling over bg rocks though.
Jeep Wranglers are also capable, but cramped and can't tow enough.

Sent from my GT-P5210 using AULRO mobile app

After that comparo, I had to wonder if I bought the "right stuff".

The jeeps axle clearance/angle astonished me. I was impressed.

That said, would have been better to compare a 90 not a 110.

Great video though.