I'm convinced that it is easy to be fooled into thinking that a change in the amount of power available constitutes a lot of power available.
I have seen a few instances of that over the years. When I was at uni, I borrowed a friend's step-through Honda 50 a few times and was quite impressed with its acceleration, so I arranged a drag race with a mate who drove a 1934 Chev. I had been a passenger in the Chev a few times and had never felt any burst of power.
The race was an embarrassing defeat for the Honda. The constant torque of the Chev engine was more than a match for the burst of power from the Honda when it hit the power band.
Years later when Honda brought out the two stroke MT 125, I owned a four stroke SL 125. When I rode the MT, I was convinced that it accelerated much more quickly than my SL125, so I arranged another drag race. The result was that the four stroke and the two stroke had identical acceleration. The difference was that the two stroke lagged behind while it was out of the power band and surged forward when it was got into the powerband. The surge of power when it hit the power band had confused me. The four stroke SL125 was a fairly extreme example of a constant delivery of power (even if there wasn't much power). In fact between about 2,000 and 9,000 revs, the torque never fell below 92% of maximum torque. Torque curves don't get much flatter than that.
The constant torque of the SL125 is probably similar to the torque delivery of the 4BD1T. It helps if the torque is there all the time.
A similar misconception is common in the kayaking world. I have known a lot of people swear blind that a SOF is faster than a rigid hull. They are confusing responsiveness with speed. A light SOF (or indeed any light kayak) surges forward with every paddle stroke while a heavy kayak gradually builds up speed. They might have the same top speed but the lighter kayak feels faster because you can feel the response to every paddle stroke. I have a SOF as well as my strip built kayaks and my data logger tells me that the SOF is no faster than the rigid hull kayaks with similar dimensions.
If the supply of torque is constant, it is easy to believe that there isn't much power available and if there is a surge of power, it is easy to forget that it wasn't there all the time.


Reply With Quote



Bookmarks