Thread: Won’t be retro...

Originally Posted by Zeros

Meh. Looks like a Commodore to me.[/QUOTE]

Which nearly every red blooded Aussie loves

#classycommodore

Originally Posted by Zeros

Critiquing vehicle brands and comparing is a central component of the DNA of this forum. It’s only when people take it personally for whatever reason that it becomes ugly. A critique or comparison between vehicle or brands is not a personal criticism otherwise.

Any dark coloured roof will always make a vehicle hotter than a light coloured roof, unless the roof is insulated. Weeds your roof would be insulated with the Mulgo Conversion?, so black not so much of an issue?

Agreed, however we must remember this is a LR owners forum not a 4x4 forum like pirate(irate), there is a huge difference between bashing everything JLR and mixing genuine and warranted criticism with credit where its due. If someone is 99% criticism imo this forum is not for them.
People are always going to stand up for their brand, standing up for the land rover you love is also a big part of this forum, so its going to happen

Originally Posted by ozscott

Black roofs look great. Just they absorb heat. Having said that if you have a roof rack on and touring with gear up top that takes the sting out. If shiny black that helps. Mine is dark metallic grey so not a lot better than metallic black. Cheers

Actually ... the RACQ did some tests on black cars vs white cars and found minimal differences in heat absorption and the rate at which they heated up - the interiors of the white cars were only a little cooler.


Temperature in Cars Survey - RACQhttps://www.racq.com.au/.../racq%20pdfs/cars%20and%20driving/.../0814_temperatur...


They concluded that:

"This suggests that vehicle paint colour has very little impact on interior temperatures and rate of rise .... colour has negligible impact on the rate of temperature rise"

I think the tropical roof would be cooler because of the air gap, not the colour.
Both our camper trailers have tropical roofs, one blue and one fawn, but despite not being white they make a big difference to the internal temperature.

Originally Posted by DiscoMick

I think the tropical roof would be cooler because of the air gap, not the colour.
Both our camper trailers have tropical roofs, one blue and one fawn, but despite not being white they make a big difference to the internal temperature.

The airgap and the colour both make it cooler, but the airgap makes a bigger difference. Without the airgap the colour is more important.

Originally Posted by Arapiles

Actually ... the RACQ did some tests on black cars vs white cars and found minimal differences in heat absorption and the rate at which they heated up - the interiors of the white cars were only a little cooler.


Temperature in Cars Survey - RACQhttps://www.racq.com.au/.../racq%20pdfs/cars%20and%20driving/.../0814_temperatur...


They concluded that:

"This suggests that vehicle paint colour has very little impact on interior temperatures and rate of rise .... colour has negligible impact on the rate of temperature rise"

The results clearly state that the dark blue coloured car was 3 degrees hotter inside than the white car. I suggest that a black car would be another degree hotter.

My D2a is a very dark blue and my wifes little "Buzz Box" is blindingly white and yet the interior of the buzz box is always far hotter than the Disco.

Originally Posted by Zeros

Critiquing vehicle brands and comparing is a central component of the DNA of this forum. It’s only when people take it personally for whatever reason that it becomes ugly. A critique or comparison between vehicle or brands is not a personal criticism otherwise.

Exactly,well said.

One of your recent posts is a very good example,short,sweet,and onto the facts.Fine.Nothing wrong with that at all.

Those types of posts are what this site is about.

This is a public forum,people have their opinions and views.

What i don't think people on here want to see is continual, long winded, ongoing posts criticising and 'bashing' other brands.

Its not what this place is about.