Page 1 of 6 123 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 55

Thread: A good response to the morally outraged masses

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    Yass NSW
    Posts
    2,753

    A good response to the morally outraged masses

    I have been contemplating the rage and anger that seems to abound in society these days and which has morphed from the "keyboard warrior in his mothers basement" to become a mainstream sport heartily supported by the reality TV and mainstream media. Micheal Leunig wrote the following response to the outrage that his cartoon the other day drew and I think it expresses the problem far more eloquently than I could.
    Link to article: Michael Leunig on Instagram mum cartoon controversy: Aiming to stir the possum, I got engulfed in free-floating hate

    It was exactly 50 years ago that I started working as a full-time newspaper cartoonist, and as if to celebrate this anniversary, mysterious fate had me drawing a cartoon which brought so much hostile public reaction that I began to lie awake at night wondering why I had followed such a troubled, painful and precarious career path.

    In the offending cartoon I drew a mother with her eyes glued to a phone and wheeling a pram from which her baby had fallen completely unnoticed. The child lies abandoned on the footpath behind mother, wishing that he was as interesting as her phone. Black humour indeed but making a worthy point about the perils and disasters of the phone addiction which is spreading across the world like a plague.
    A newspaper cartoonist can be something of a natural anthropologist; a keen observer of society with a sense of impending cultural change and its possible tragedies. Like many others I had been noticing with sadness the growing number of parents lost in their phone screens while wheeling babies in prams through busy streets. Heaven only knows what goes on in the home. Negligence caused by distraction is the issue. The roads are becoming deadlier because of it, and God only knows what other failures and disasters are being caused by phone addiction.
    I drew a mother not out of misogyny but because of my lifelong special interest in the mother-infant relationship and all that is at stake in that early connection. For many years I have pored over the marvellous works of Donald Winnicott, the great English paediatrician and psychoanalyst, who gave us the idea of the "good enough mother"¯ and identified and described in much detail what he called the "primary maternal preoccupation"¯. This refers to the natural deeply attuned attention that in most cases a mother gives to the baby which has just emerged from her womb - and all the vital developmental facilitation that is set up in the child through this deep connection at the start of life.


    To paraphrase Winnicott: the attentive loving eye contact made by mother with the baby is crucial in the child's developmental process. It is this sustained meeting of eyes between mother and infant which activates the development of the baby's sense of a secure self. The baby needs to be seen; it needs to be held in the mother's gaze as well as the mother's arms. What the father can do best at this point is to protect and nourish the flourishing of this early mother-child connection.
    All of my life I have been fascinated by the talk of mothers, grandmothers, aunties, sisters, spouses and offspring about this ancient business of mothering, where we all began. In ordinary homes and around kitchen tables I was witness to a lot of this passionate conversation about the best way to care for a baby and raise a child. It is one of the great eternally interesting topics for discussion, and what is at stake makes it more important than most political debates could ever be. I listened and took it in. A real misogynist would not respect these maternal matters so devoutly.

    Just as we are disturbed to hear tales that certain migratory birds are mysteriously losing their ability to navigate due to human environmental damage, so too might we feel concern if growing numbers of human mothers seem to be losing or devaluing this primary maternal preoccupation in favour of the banal hypnotic charms of a phone screen. Nature would seem to be in trouble when this starts to happen.

    To make a conscientious cartoon based upon all of this concern and then be so hated, insulted, slandered in the public domain for this - as I was - is indeed a dismal fate for the lone cartoonist. It speaks volumes about the current condition of civil society and tolerance. This is bigotry. The malice has been astounding and so extreme that it has plunged me into a deep contemplation about the nature of angry hatred. Indeed, I am coming to the view that there is an emerging new form of hatred in society which might be more of a mental illness than a passing emotion. Perhaps I would call it "free-floating, obsessive compulsive hatred"¯.

    In looking at my part in this upset, I have wondered if it is my working-class background, with its raw language and earthy humour, that has caused an offending bluntness. This rawness has always informed the spirit of my work and humour, a spirit which for some may seem archaic and somehow inappropriate in the age of woke identity politics.
    I learned in the streets of Footscray that a little dark humour can shed plenty of light. There was a lot of life and death in the slaughterhouses where I worked as a labourer before my career as an artist began, and this promotes a lot of philosophy and wonder. The cartooning sensibility that develops in such places may seem at odds with the more clean educated environment of these anxious and brittle times but remarkably, although my bloodstained workmates were fairly rough and ready, I never saw in them the same sadistic anger that has been dished out to me in words by my educated critics during my time as a cartoonist. As a friend said to me recently, "remember the good old days when you had to call someone a stupid bastard to cause offence, now if you just point out the bleeding obvious you can be denounced, hated, insulted, condemned and punished"¯.
    I have noticed that people can react to a cartoon as if it is a piece of legislation, an essay, a legal document or a scientific paper - but obviously it is none of these things. A cartoon is a simple allegory, a fable or a parable. It is better understood poetically than literally. And it is also a Rorschach test, often revealing something about the character of the beholder in their expressed interpretations.

    I heard of an academic denouncing my mother-and-pram cartoon by saying that I had failed to take this thing and that thing into account. On and on she went, pointing out the failures of the cartoon and demolishing it and me.
    But did the academic consider that I may have taken all those missing things into account but chosen not to spoil the plain and simple truth of the cartoon by including so much messy detail? Unlike the academic, the artist happily leaves many things to the common sense imagination.

    But let's face it, a good editorial cartoon stirs the possum. It is meant to. No offence is intended but with humans being what they are, offence is inevitable. Humans are anxious creatures and you canā€™t please them all. Anxiety can produce anger. Anger may lead to hatred. Hatred gives energy, meaning and purpose to insecure lives and is a free pass to the gratification of unrestrained malice. Once it becomes collective, the malice becomes its own monster. Then it starts to hurt.
    Yet in all of this kerfuffle and madness the messages of support come in steadily, from men and women equally and from all over Australia, intelligent words that reinforce my observations on this matter of mother, baby and phone, and reassure me that sanity and decency go on quietly in the background. Yes, the newspaper cartoonist must always hear criticism and always examine their conscience but the first allegiance must not be to sentimental notions of motherhood but to raw truth.

    And when all is said and done if just one parent, one driver, one worker in a dangerous environment takes stock and wakes up and gets their phone addiction under control as a result of this controversy, then all these bruises and sleepless nights will not have been in vain.


    The disconnection from reality of many people today leaves me wondering how they would survive in the world that they would wish for:

    Vegans living in a world without the evil aguiculture conglomerates to make their beetroot and soy bleeding burgers
    Mining demonstrators having to live without any of the benefits that mining brings
    Climate change protesters pushing a wheelbarrow across australia with their belongings in it to spread their message without generating greenhouse gases (wheelbarrows and bicicycles were a common method of transport in the 1880s)

    Perhaps in the bigger scheme of things I am worrying about nothing and society will sort itself out, if you read newspapers from 100 years ago there are plenty of "Moral Panics" that seem rediculous tooday and I was heartened to hear of the test case of a reality TV show's participants being legally regarded as "workers" for the purposes of compensation.

    Regards,
    Tote
    Go home, your igloo is on fire....
    MY2016 Aintree Green Defender 130 Cab Chassis
    2007 Discovery 3 - Gone
    Discovery 2 SE - Gone
    Discovery 1 TDI300- Gone
    1957 Series 1 107 ute - In pieces
    1955 Series 1 86 - parts
    Assorted Falcons and Jeeps.....

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Jul 2019
    Location
    EastnSubsMelb
    Posts
    297
    To quote a line from one of my Mrs favorite chick flicks,(DuetsA good response to the morally outraged masses)..
    "I think Society has lost its finesse"

  3. #3
    Homestar's Avatar
    Homestar is offline Super Moderator & CA manager Gold Subscriber
    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Location
    Sunbury, VIC
    Posts
    16,766
    Geez, that cartoon was tame IMO. People just want to be offended for the sake of it or maybe the truth of it struck a little too close to home for some... 😉


    1977 101 FC - 'Chucky'
    1986 Classic RR - 'Thing'
    1976 Series III Tray
    1997 Honda CBR1000F
    2003 L322 - Gone to a new home.

    'Love with your heart - use your head for everything else.' - CaptainDisillusion

  4. #4
    Join Date
    May 2017
    Location
    Melbourne
    Posts
    741
    And you think that it's only the left that feels disproportionate outrage? I was in Canada recently and they were dealing with a mass killer who identified as an "Incel" - that is, a young man who was involuntarily celibate - so he hired a van and went out and ran over random strangers because they were "Chads" and "Staceys" in his world view, that is people who were probably in normal sexual relationships.

    BTW, it's not the first time that Leunig has been accused of misogyny, so he has form.
    Arapiles
    2014 D4 HSE

  5. #5
    Homestar's Avatar
    Homestar is offline Super Moderator & CA manager Gold Subscriber
    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Location
    Sunbury, VIC
    Posts
    16,766
    Quote Originally Posted by Arapiles View Post
    And you think that it's only the left that feels disproportionate outrage? I was in Canada recently and they were dealing with a mass killer who identified as an "Incel" - that is, a young man who was involuntarily celibate - so he hired a van and went out and ran over random strangers because they were "Chads" and "Staceys" in his world view, that is people who were probably in normal sexual relationships.

    BTW, it's not the first time that Leunig has been accused of misogyny, so he has form.
    Did you think the cartoon was out of line?


    1977 101 FC - 'Chucky'
    1986 Classic RR - 'Thing'
    1976 Series III Tray
    1997 Honda CBR1000F
    2003 L322 - Gone to a new home.

    'Love with your heart - use your head for everything else.' - CaptainDisillusion

  6. #6
    Join Date
    May 2017
    Location
    Melbourne
    Posts
    741
    Quote Originally Posted by Homestar View Post
    Did you think the cartoon was out of line?
    I'm wondering why he focused on women or young mothers - the City is full of people barrelling along the footpaths with their eyes on their phones and not looking where they're going. And I did a quick survey at the traffic lights when I was riding home one night and the drivers of half of the cars there were on their phones, and most were actually holding them. So, in the bigger scheme of things, I don't think that women pushing prams are the biggest issue with mobile phone use.
    Arapiles
    2014 D4 HSE

  7. #7
    Join Date
    May 2017
    Location
    Melbourne
    Posts
    741

    Leunig has form ....

    Oh, and there was this - women who use creches or childcare are bad people - "cruel, ignorant, selfish bitch":


    [IMG]https://miro.medium.com/max/546/1*IEBZ1kAf7caq5uBYVR1_QA.jpeg[/IMG]



    And this, where he outs himself as an ant-laxer:

    [IMG]https://miro.medium.com/max/1136/1*C6ScAPXbJvaaROGtlwVCPw.jpeg[/IMG]
    Arapiles
    2014 D4 HSE

  8. #8
    Homestar's Avatar
    Homestar is offline Super Moderator & CA manager Gold Subscriber
    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Location
    Sunbury, VIC
    Posts
    16,766
    Quote Originally Posted by Arapiles View Post
    I'm wondering why he focused on women or young mothers - the City is full of people barrelling along the footpaths with their eyes on their phones and not looking where they're going. And I did a quick survey at the traffic lights when I was riding home one night and the drivers of half of the cars there were on their phones, and most were actually holding them. So, in the bigger scheme of things, I don't think that women pushing prams are the biggest issue with mobile phone use.
    I think people read too much into stuff these days - if he’d used another example he’d be in trouble for that - lose lose these days with all this mock outrage going around. Why can’t people just get a laugh out of some observational humour. If he’d used a fat middle aged white guy with glasses I wouldn’t have been offended...

    IMO life’s too short for BS like this, not sure why everyone can’t just get through their short existences without making life hard for others for no reason.

    Live and let live, it’s far easier on the blood pressure. 👍😊
    Last edited by Homestar; 1st November 2019 at 08:31 PM.


    1977 101 FC - 'Chucky'
    1986 Classic RR - 'Thing'
    1976 Series III Tray
    1997 Honda CBR1000F
    2003 L322 - Gone to a new home.

    'Love with your heart - use your head for everything else.' - CaptainDisillusion

  9. #9
    Homestar's Avatar
    Homestar is offline Super Moderator & CA manager Gold Subscriber
    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Location
    Sunbury, VIC
    Posts
    16,766
    Quote Originally Posted by Arapiles View Post
    Oh, and there was this - women who use creches or childcare are bad people - "cruel, ignorant, selfish bitch":


    [IMG]https://miro.medium.com/max/546/1*IEBZ1kAf7caq5uBYVR1_QA.jpeg[/IMG]



    And this, where he outs himself as an ant-laxer:

    [IMG]https://miro.medium.com/max/1136/1*C6ScAPXbJvaaROGtlwVCPw.jpeg[/IMG]
    So your outrage here is aimed at Leunig overall as you don’t like his work? Each to their own, and that’s fine by me👍. I don’t agree with some of his views but I won’t go condemning him or others for their views - hardly extreme by today’s standards. As I said in my last post, life’s too short to be angry at everyone all the time.


    1977 101 FC - 'Chucky'
    1986 Classic RR - 'Thing'
    1976 Series III Tray
    1997 Honda CBR1000F
    2003 L322 - Gone to a new home.

    'Love with your heart - use your head for everything else.' - CaptainDisillusion

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Jul 2019
    Location
    EastnSubsMelb
    Posts
    297
    What a hoot!
    This thread has already become the case in point!
    Hehe, too funny. Didn't take long. A good response to the morally outraged masses
    Oh, and before anyone asks, yes the view here, atop of my horse is brilliant. Little bit warm tonight, but still.... A good response to the morally outraged massesA good response to the morally outraged masses

Page 1 of 6 123 ... LastLast

Tags for this Thread

Bookmarks

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Search AULRO.com ONLY!
Search All the Web!